In Poland, Even Winnie-the-Pooh Has a Holocaust Story


10 min read
5 min read
3 min read
Depression doesn't always look like what you think.
From the outside, my life appears full. I'm a 66-year-old married woman living in Israel. I have family, friends, interests and responsibilities. Nothing about my life suggests depression.
Yet depression rarely looks the way people expect.
It doesn't always keep you in bed or prevent you from functioning. Sometimes it lets you smile at a neighbor, attend synagogue, answer emails and make dinner while quietly convincing you that you're completely alone.
For years, I believed I was the only one.
Women of my generation weren't taught to speak about depression. We were taught to persevere, care for others and keep our struggles private. If we were hurting, we simply tried harder.
Depression doesn't care how resilient you are. It doesn't respect faith, determination or willpower.
But depression doesn't care how resilient you are. It doesn't respect faith, determination or willpower. It arrives uninvited, even on days when everything around you seems perfectly normal.
Medication has helped me enormously and I'm grateful for it. Still, anxiety can return without warning. A wave of dread washes over me. Nights are often the hardest. I sleep but I don't always feel rested. Sometimes I find myself wishing for a magic switch that could stop the panic before it gathers momentum.
When anxiety takes over, it becomes physical. My chest tightens, swallowing feels difficult. I feel as though I'm drowning while standing perfectly still. My thoughts race toward death, dementia and every frightening possibility.
That may be depression's greatest deception. It convinces us our fear is telling the truth.
There are days when simply moving through ordinary life requires tremendous effort. The world keeps turning while my mind feels trapped on a grotesque merry-go-round I can't escape.
Yet the hardest part is the loneliness, the aching belief that no one else could possibly understand.
Over time, I've discovered that this is another lie depression tells.
Many people carry invisible burdens. They sit beside us in synagogue, greet us warmly in the grocery store, celebrate family milestones and go to work each day while fighting battles no one else can see.
Therapy and medication matter, but sometimes what we need most is another human being who understands, someone who listens and doesn't rush to fix us.
Someone who can simply say, "I've been there."
Silence feeds loneliness, while honesty begins to break its hold.
That's why I've decided to tell my story. Because silence feeds loneliness, while honesty begins to break its hold.
If you're wondering whether anyone understands what you're are going through, I want you to know this: You are not alone.
I still have difficult days. I still ask God why this has become part of my journey. I don't pretend to understand His reasons.
But I've begun to see that sometimes His answer comes through other people, through a conversation, a listening ear or someone willing to say, "I know that feeling."
If hearing from someone who's walked this road would help, I'd be honored to talk with you. Sometimes healing begins not with a solution, but with the realization that someone else truly understands.
Hope begins when we reach for one another.

Never go to bed if you have eaten a full meal less than 2 hours previously. I found that this made an enormous difference to my mood when I woke in the morning.
"He who HESITATES is lost"
Procrastination may be related to depression. "Timing is everything"
TIME backwards is EMIT. I would appreciate any comments. Thanks, much
Thanks for this comment, Harry. Very interesting.
Thank you for this thoughtful article, it really came at a time when I needed to hear it. I’m a retired psychiatric nurse 66yrs old and I’m experiencing extreme anxiety. I feel emotionally drained and I can’t be there for my family right now. It’s as if anxiety and fear grips me when I think they are requiring me to do something for them. I took care of my sister who died of cancer and my father who had dementia ( both have passed away) and now my husband has health problems, I can’t handle much else right now. Your article gave me hope.
Rose, keep the hope alive as much as you can.
I notice that I have times throughout the day that I experience anxiety and the hope dwindles at those moments.
I have tried the 3, 2, 1 method of Aaron Washburn when I am anxious and it helps. Link is here: https://vimeo.com/872152655/77fffd8afa
His method involves just catching your breath and hugging yourself to get a tactile grip on the moment and draw yourself back in to reality.
SHA(LO)M = SHAM LO (His name)
Shalom, Peace can be split into two words, Sham and Lo, as shown
I suggest that we can have more Shalom, by giving HaShem and others more credit.
Giving CREDIT can include works, deeds, money, trust, friendship, mention, etc/
For example, we can give you and Aish.com some credit for this helpful story.
(I would appreciate your comments, and comments from Aish.com editors on this)
CREDIT Yourself, more?
Let me add, that we ask for credit, for our labor, still, time, experience, caring, etc.
It might sometimes help, to LIST some steps we have gone thought in helping others.
Life is trial and error for us all. There are stories behind our efforts, which others might
not easily appreciate. And, we might not appreciate the efforts of others, until we take
the time to express something about the effort... Thanks so much much for sharing...
Sending you all my best wishes for success (and credit) in all you do, Harry. Thank you for taking the time to post your comments on this article.
I wonder if the author has kosher medications. Otherwise it could very well be that the medication that is proclaimed as the "healer" is the culprit of the depression.
Also, antidepressants and antipsychotics have depression and suicidal ideation as possible side effects.
I actually experienced significantly better mood without pills than with them. By contrast, I had suicidal thoughts and "resistant" depression on medications.
It also seemed that kosher mezuzot helped greatly.
Thank you for reading this essay and for taking the time to comment. Interesting perspective — I will see about my mezuzot.
Greatly appreciate this. My daughter has suffered from anxiety, depression and suicidal tendencies since she was 12. Her most prominent comment was no one understood how she felt and that there was something wrong with her. She’s now 35, engaged to be married and doing well but I worry every day that her happiness is temporary and that she would never survive a life changing, negative event. As her mom my biggest complaint was that no one wanted to talk about mental health and that silence supported her feeling that she was not normal. As an adult she had a brain scan to find out what was wrong with her and the psychiatrist said it showed abnormalities. I asked her to define “normal” and she realized that description may not have been the best. Everyone has their own normal.
Depression is hard on the person suffering with it and difficult for family, friends and loved ones, too. Trying to keep your worries in check is a learning experience for you as mom, as well.
I have lived with depression for decades. Long ago I received psychiatric therapy but it didn't help. Today I've found friendship and connection in 12 step groups. Please reach out to me.
12-step groups are indeed a terrific resource. Here in Israel they exist but in Jerusalem especially it's hard for me to get to meetings. Good idea, though. Thank you for your comment and offer to help, I appreciate it.
Just to say thank you for your honesty. So helpful, and so true that we can mostly somehow summon up the strength to carry on and smile at our neighbours and the shop assistant, make a friendly comment and then go home and weep and fight our hidden battles alone. Thank you thank you and may you receive the kindness and understanding you need to cope with this cruel and often misunderstood illness.
Thank you for taking the time to comment. And may you strive to live with the characteristic that your name evokes.
The big problem is when someone you love feels like this, rejects any kind of treatment or medicaction, and is absolutely sure that nobody else understands, nobody else could feel this, because life treated them wrong. It is so frustrating.
Judaism knows of angels. With certainty.
Doctors and especially psychiatrists regularly claim that angels don't exist or that G-d doesn't exist or both. Same with ghosts.
Don't dismiss it as a mental illness when someone says that they heard an angel or a ghost or a demon.
I'm not saying that you - the commentator - are, but rather that it seems to be a common refrain in this "issue".
Angels exist of course. I did not understand the rest. You mean the person you love and try to support sees you as angel or demon? I would love to help see the good in life.But sometimes the depresised cannot.
I, too, have a family member who denies himself treatment for a mental illness. It's rough to stand by and watch them spiral out of control year after year. It is so frustrating, yes.
Years of depression here too! Since birth.
Hospitalizations.
So Many drugs, many modalities. Many years lost.
Finally tested for nutrient deficiencies.
Good to great results.
Test first, then treat.
Great to hear about this. Good idea to test.
I meant, of course, great to hear about the idea to test for nutrient deficiencies. Good that you got great results from the testing and fixing of the deficiencies.
wow thank you for sharing this - i am also on this journey and i am trying different nutrient therapies. It is so nice to hear that you are doing better.
Negative emotions continuously generate toxins in the body.
4. High sensitivity and absorption of external negative energy: Highly sensitive individuals easily absorb the anxiety or low-spirited moods of others, causing their own energy fields to become completely depleted.
III. Root causes at the spiritual level
1. Loss of soul direction and detachment from one’s spiritual ideals; the inner "Higher Self" becomes disconnected from the physical body, resulting in a lack of inner sustaining strength.
2. Excessive self-isolation, severing connections related to serving and giving to others; the flow of life stagnates, and energy that only enters without flowing out leads to blockages and a state of despondency.
what a thoughtful and comprehensive analysis, Eva. Thank you for posting this.
II. Psychological and Emotional Roots (The Mental Realm)
The mind is the builder of the body; chronic negative thoughts can solidify into physical ailments:
1. Self-condemnation and internal judgment: The most destructive emotional patterns. Prolonged guilt, self-reproach, and an inability to forgive oneself—characterized by a continuous inward attack—directly suppress nervous vitality.
2. Collapse of ideals and loss of life’s anchor: A lack of spiritual purpose leads to emptiness and hopelessness—essentially the "loss of life ideals." Once spiritual energy is depleted, this state devolves into depression.
3. Suppression of resentment, grievances, and hostility: Anger that is not released normally accumulates internally, transforming into a state of despondency.
2. Systemic accumulation of endogenous toxins (autointoxication)
When the liver, intestines, and kidneys fail to eliminate toxins effectively, metabolic toxins seep into nerve fibers and paralyze the nervous system. This causes neural "dulling," directly triggering feelings of low mood and numbness.
Sources of toxins: Overeating, consumption of highly processed foods, constipation, weak digestion, and poor metabolism due to staying up late.
3. Spinal misalignment and compression of nerve pathways
Misalignment of the cervical spine or upper thoracic spine can compress the sympathetic and parasympathetic nerves connecting to the brain, obstructing blood supply and signal transmission to the central nervous system. Depression stemming from this cause responds poorly to psychological
Depression is a complex condition stemming from an imbalance of body, mind, and spirit. Its pathology involves a failure in nerve impulse transmission: the brain generates the intention to act, but the nerves are unable to relay the corresponding commands.
1. Endocrine gland dysfunction (the primary physiological trigger)
The functioning of the nervous system relies entirely on biochemical substances secreted by glands; glandular imbalances directly disrupt the transmission of nerve signals:
- Adrenal glands: Chronic stress leads to exhaustion and disrupted cortisol secretion, resulting in depleted energy and low mood.
- Thyroid gland: Hypofunction slows down systemic metabolism, accompanied by fatigue, excessive sleepiness, and a loss of interest.
- Pineal gland:
A heartbreaking essay. It saddens me to read about the suffering this woman is in, enough for her to write about her issue on a first person basis.
Surely Hashem helps, had helped, and will continue to help this woman. May it be so!
Such suffering affects men too.
Thank you for your kind words. I'm here also if anyone wants to reach out.
how can i reach you
Hi Erez — There's a contact link at RochelGrosz.com.