Jimmy Stewart vs. the Nazis


7 min read
3 min read
3 min read
Our enemies love nothing more than to see us turn on each other, to weaken us from within, to turn us into our own enemies. We cannot let that happen.
For me, the past two days have, in a way, been more difficult than the hours and days following the Black Sabbath, October 7th. I don’t know if it’s just resurfacing the unprocessed pain that I never fully came to grips with. Perhaps it was the crushing blow when, after so many months, we were beginning to see the light at the end of the tunnel. Regardless of the source, my body feels heavy and broken.
In times of profound crisis, the pain we feel can be overwhelming, and naturally, we look for a way to relieve our suffering. After all, as a mentor of mine, Rabbi Asher Resnick, often quotes after experiencing his own share of tragedy that no one should ever know, “Pain is a reality but suffering is a choice."
It pains me to no end to see the choices that so many of my fellow Jews are making. Some are looking for people to blame in the hope that it will relieve our suffering. But it only deepens our pain.
I recently saw a post that so beautifully captured what I was feeling but found difficult to put into words: "This morning felt like October 7th. Now it feels like October 6th (referring to the period of time in Israel when disunity and the fear of civil war were in the air). Let's remember we have a common enemy, and it's not each other."
This sentiment captures the essence of what so many of us are feeling right now. The events of October 7th were a horrific wake-up call, reminding us of the relentless threat we face from those who seek to destroy us. But they were also a unifying call to come together.
When I went to Israel in November, just weeks after October 7th, I witnessed an indescribable unity among our people. It was a profound unity born out of shared pain and a deep sense of family.
But as the days turned into weeks and weeks into months, the unity that followed that dark day has begun to fray, leaving us vulnerable to division.
Today we find ourselves torn between two equally compelling and agonizing perspectives within our community. These perspectives are not just abstract ideas but are rooted in the raw, real emotions of a family that has endured unimaginable pain.
On one side, there are those who passionately argue that Israel must do everything in its power to secure the release of the hostages. The pain of knowing that our loved ones, our brothers and sisters, are in the hands of a merciless enemy, and that we are running out of time to save them is unbearable. If it were my family member being held captive, I, too, would be desperate for any action that might bring them home safely. The desire to see our captives come home alive is a top priority for a nation that values life above all.
On the other side, there are those who caution that we must be wary of making concessions that could allow Hamas to repeat the atrocities of October 7th. For example, Hamas has demanded that Israel withdraw from the Philadelphi Corridor, a move that would likely lead to the smuggling of weapons into Gaza once again and increase the likelihood of future attacks.
Releasing known terrorists and giving them the ability to restructure and rearm while they are still telling us and the world that they plan to repeat the atrocities would mean risking the security of Israel's future and repeating this cycle of terror instead of breaking it once and for all. Remember, Yahya Sinwar, the leader of Hamas and mastermind of the October 7th attacks, was released in a similar hostage deal.
These are not easy choices. They are heart-wrenching dilemmas with no cut and dry answers. Both sides have legitimate concerns, and both are motivated by the desire to protect our people, whether by ensuring their immediate safety or by safeguarding our nation's long-term security.
I am torn and don't know which side is “right.” But what I do know is this: our brothers and sisters are not the enemy.
Our collective outrage should be directed at Hamas and those who support them, not at each other.
We cannot allow ourselves to become divided by these differences. Our enemies love nothing more than to see us turn on each other, to weaken us from within, to turn us into our own enemies. We cannot let that happen.
Our collective outrage should be directed at Hamas and those who support them, who started this war by brutally slaughtering 1200 innocent people, and who just executed six beautiful souls in cold blood for the crime of being Jewish.
We need to hold onto that unity, to remember that, as different as our perspectives might be, we are all on the same side. We must come together again like we did on October 8th and not revert to the division we faced on October 6th.
Byachad n'natzeiach—together, we will prevail. It is only by standing together, as one people, that we can overcome the challenges before us and ensure a safer, stronger future for Israel, the Jewish People, and the entire world.

you expressed so much of what i and others have been feeling. torn between the two sides, while understandng each's reasoning. we must all stand together. Hamas, Iran would like nothing better than seeing us Jews battle each other
Wise words indeed.
Oh.. I thought this article would be along the lines of knowing that not a single Man or Woman is truly an enemy. To take all the inward and outwardly-seen suffering to YHUH and receive Hope and solutions...and see from the perspective of the One who put the Breath of Life in all equally, and who sees us all as His beloved children.
Peace Will be achieved through the revelation of that all-consuming Love in each Heart. And so it is 🌈
It just dawned on me that, worse than losing one of the very young children that were taken on Oct 7, would be the thought that a child may be given to a Palestinian couple to raise with the beliefs of Hamas against his/her own people.
I am a Christian who stands with Israel. I, too, find each day's news gut-wrenching dilemmas. The recent murder of 6 just before they were rescued shows the evil that is facing Israel. I remember the news after Noa and company were rescued, there was directive from hamas that all other hostages be executed before rescue.
I know many won't agree, but I believe PM Netanyahu has been placed in position for such a time as this. A lesser person would've caved in to the incredible demands both from within and without. It's human nature to look for blame for tragic events and the government is the most convenient. But, "a kingdom divided against itself is laid waste.. a house divided against itself will not stand. I pray for HaShem's miraculous intervention. Then the world will see the truth.
Wow! what a beautidul article that managed to convey the emotions i feel so perfectly!
may we merit to see unity amongst our people and the safety of ALL israeli citizens and Jews the world over very very soon!
In the middle of what is happening in Israel, there will be a new election o in November,(in the united states) one side is Kamla Harris and the other side Donald Trump and unfortunately some Jews will vote for Kamla Harris that favors the terrorists and not Jews/Israel, so besides the turmoil in Israel, only Hashem will no know the answer who will the new president in America and how Israel will be affected/effected by that outcome, I am very worried for both America and Israel will it be a good outcome for both countries or not, we must all pray for the best
While I agree with the goal of Jewish unity, I take exception to the notion that "our collective outrage should be directed at Hamas and those who support them". Our enemies enjoy seeing us outraged.
You do not feel outrage at a mad dog. You just put the dog down. This applies not just to the vast majority of Arabs, but their supporters as well. Of course, these creatures are different from mad dogs. Mad dogs did not choose to be infected with rabies. The Arabs and their supporters CHOSE their anti-human status. They deserve to be treated accordingly.
Some dogs are service dogs, and other dogs are helping the soldiers or police, and some dogs are therapy dogs, the terrorists besides murdering people(and doing other evil vile things against our people) that killed people's pets, no organzations spoke up what they did to the Jews, to the women, or to the pets, these Muslim Arab terrorists is like a Holocaust Survivor from the kibbutz in the south said They are Nazis(may their name be erased) that speak Arabic, so to me that answers the question, the enemy our not mad dogs they are mad anti semitic Nazis(may their name be erased), the Holocaust Survivor was on point with her remark, my mother(obm)was also a Holocaust Survivor and see their hatred in their eyes, the Nazis got drunk to kill, and the terrorists took drugs to kill
These terrorists & all of their ilk, are made drunk by the blood of children. They spread their "yetzer hara" to the hearts of wailing mothers, hoping to capture the sympathy of an apathetic world.
Abraham Avinu pleaded with Hashem to spare Sodom if first 50, and eventually 10, righteous people could be found there. Not every Arab agrees with Hamas. We should not be so arrogant as to believe that there are no decent Arabs. In the case of women, many are virtual prisoners, and young children have no control over the actions of adults.
Blame the terrorists. Support Israel. Pray for peace.
I am not an Israeli citizen. On political crises in general, I think that contacting politicians individually may be more effective than attending protests. Why provide fodder for our enemies by publicly opposing our government?
Absolutely true. There isn't a person who doesn't pray for hostages to come home safe and sound. No one has dry eyes on this. The question is how to do it without creating many more victims in the future. The law of unintended consequences is alive and well, and these decisions needs to be made rationally, rather than emotionally. Putting pressure on the government makes it even harder for them to make sound decisions. It is likely to make things worse, not better. If those protesting would just slow down a bit to think about the unintended consequences of bringing home the hostages at the cost of many more future victims, countless lives will be saved.
The sad fact is are the hostages dead or alive, in the time of the Holocaust the odds were not good, the hostsges were alive for 11 months when the soldiers came to rescue them the terrorists killed them, it is heartbreaking to hear this tragedy that happened on oct 7 and afterwards, in the time of the Holocaust the world did not speak up for the Jews, now instead of being with the Jews and Israel the topsy turvy world are with the evil vile terrorists so the world didn't change from 1945 till 2024
So true. Amen
Great article! Shalom 🙂
Bravo for expressing how I feel! Unity is our strength and we must not falter. The enemy knows this all too well.
Excellent article!! Well put!!
This is a complex and painful issue. Jews have a long history of being strident in expressing their opinions, driven by a subconscious belief that there is an absolute truth—a sense instilled at Sinai with the giving of the Torah. Even if many have lost sight of what that truth is, the deep conviction that there is a truth persists. This can lead to a strong assertion of whatever they now believe to be true, often clashing with others who hold different views. It makes unity challenging, especially when we see those differing opinions as potentially harmful. Yet, God values our love for each other above all. So, we must find a way to balance holding firm in our beliefs with loving and respecting those who differ from us.
SO TRUE! Well put. We've been put into ceaselessly agonizing dilemmas by our enemies, precisely because we are democratic humanists who value ALL life. Above all else, we must NOT turn on or demonize each other.
Excellent article and timely for Rosh Chodesh Elul--Achdus can be difficult and it takes effort. We need to work on it at this time. Maybe all the time.
Thank you for sharing your words of wisdom!
YES!
You are so right!