Location of Prophecy

MOST POPULAR QUESTIONS
Advertisements
Advertisements

1 min read

FacebookLinkedInXPrintFriendlyShare

You wrote previously that Israel is the only land conducive to prophecy, the highest level of communion with God. All the prophets either received prophecies in Israel, or prophecies that related to the Land of Israel.

Yet the prophet Ezekiel lived in Babylon and prophesied there. Isn't that a contradiction?

The Aish Rabbi Replies

Actually, before the Jewish people settled in Israel, prophecy existed everywhere if the person deserved it. Hence Abraham, Moses, Aaron, etc. all prophesied before ever having entered Israel.

Once the Jewish people officially entered Israel, prophecy could only be achieved in Israel. In the case of Ezekiel (Yechezkel), since he prophesied initially in Israel, he was able to continue to have prophecies outside as well. (source: Rashi – Ezekiel 1:3)

→ Ask the Rabbi a Question ← Click here to comment on this article
guest
2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Aharon
Aharon
2 years ago

Hi. Where is the mkor for saying nevua can only be in Israel?

And if there is a mkor. Is it a halachic mkor that is written in Rambam?

drosenfeld
Admin
drosenfeld
1 year ago
Reply to  Aharon

Hi,

One source is Talmud Moed Kattan 25a - which explains that the prophet Ezekiel was able to receive prophecy in Babylonia because his prophecy began in the Land of Israel and so continued even outside it. Rashi to Ezekiel (1:3) likewise quotes this from the Mechilta (a halachic Midrash), 12:1.

Regarding the Rambam, he actually makes no mention of this law, even though he discusses the workings of prophecy at length (Yesodei HaTorah, Ch's 7-10). Some in fact want to derive that he omitted it because he felt it is not an ironclad principle. See here (Heb.) for further discussion on this.

Last edited 1 year ago by drosenfeld
EXPLORE
LEARN
MORE
Explore
Learn
Resources
Next Steps
About
Donate
Menu
Languages
Menu
Social
.