An Open Letter to Billy Crystal

Advertisements
Advertisements
November 16, 2026

5 min read

FacebookLinkedInXPrintFriendlyShare

With the world in turmoil and his friends Rob and Michele Reiner gone, Billy Crystal no longer trusts God. Here’s what I’d tell him.

Dear Billy,

You recently said on a CBS morning show that you stopped speaking to God because given the current state of the world, you no longer trust Him.

The painful loss of your dear friends, Rob and Michele Reiner, not to mention Robin Williams in 2014, only deepens the questions.

I think saying you no longer trust God is really another way of asking the age-old question: Why does God allow evil things to happen? Moses himself was plagued by this question. Allow me to share with you some thoughts, even though they will not fully answer your question.

Where Was Man?

First, it is not always fair to blame God for the terrible things that happen in this world. God did not cause one person to kill another, just as He did not cause Hitler to murder six million Jews and millions of other innocent souls. The more appropriate question is: Where was man?

Where were the millions of European neighbors who stood by while Jews were being gassed? Where was FDR, who knew about the daily gassings and could have bombed the train tracks but chose not to?

Too often, we blame God when man is at fault.

Why Doesn’t God Just Stop It?

Clearly, Rob and Michele are not to be blamed. They did everything possible to help their troubled son. The more difficult question then becomes: why couldn’t God simply stop it?

The short answer is that God created a world with free will, which means He cannot openly interfere with every human choice. The consequence of free will is pain and suffering; removing that would remove the capacity to freely choose. If God stopped every bullet from reaching its intended target, free will would be compromised and game over.

The Price of Free Will

So why give us free will, knowing the pain it would inevitably cause? Because the same potential that exists for evil also exists for good. We cannot be rewarded unless we are tested and have to choose between good and bad. A robot that is pre-programmed, similar to an angel, does not have free choice and can therefore not be rewarded, whereas man can teach untold heights if he commits himself to choosing correctly. And likewise, he can descend to untold depths of depravity. The choice is his.

Please don’t think that God did not care when the world lost Rob and Michele. They were, and still are, His children. He gave them life, and He knows the pain their loss has caused, especially to those so close to them.

You said you no longer trust God, but the truth is that we all rely on Him. We trust in Him when we are waiting for test results, getting into a car, boarding a plane, crossing the street, witnessing childbirth, or standing onstage before an audience, hoping for the best.

But relying on man? I’m not so sure. Truthfully, I can give you six million reasons as to why I don’t trust man.

Miracles, Big and Small

And while God won’t openly override free will, He does reveal Himself through the many miracles we have witnessed like the Six-Day War, the Yom Kippur War, and the recent Dubai flight that was nearly hijacked yet miraculously had no fatalities.

How many people have we heard about who should have died but went on to live for many more years than they ever expected? And what about the personal miracles we have witnessed, often dismissed as “strokes of good luck” or “coincidence”?

As Jews, we believe that Rob and Michele’s souls continue to live on and that, at the appropriate time, you will be reunited with them and with all your loved ones. The good and loving things Rob and Michele did are jewels in their crowns, and will remain with them for all eternity.

Where Love Comes From

Billy, I saw another interview in which you spoke about the first time you saw your wife and fell in love, nearly 60 years ago. The words you used to describe her were beautiful, strong, nurturing, honest, tough, assertive, compassionate.

Those same qualities could be used to describe God.

You spoke proudly of how your wife, a grandmother, began tap dancing in the hospital for her 98-year-old mother. That moment said it all.

The love you carry for your wife, children, grandchildren, work, and friends comes from God. He is the source of love and He knows everything in our hearts.

Keep Talking

God created a world in which He doesn’t openly prevent every tragedy, but that does not mean He is absent. He is there alongside us, every step of the way. Not surprisingly, the name Yisrael means “one who struggles with God.” God is always alongside us, even when we do not feel His presence.

Moses argued with God. Abraham pleaded with God. The dialogue always remained, because ignoring God would be like walking past your father without acknowledging him.

After Elie Wiesel endured hell on earth in the death camps, he said, “The Jew may love God, the Jew may fight with God, but the Jew may not ignore God.”

Billy, please keep the dialogue going. God wants to hear from you.

Click here to comment on this article
guest
0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
EXPLORE
LEARN
MORE
Explore
Learn
Resources
Next Steps
About
Donate
Menu
Languages
Menu
Social
.