Sir Isaac Newton and Judaism


8 min read
The Big Bang. Dark Matter. Sexism. Faith. Vera Rubin faced it all.
The universe is revealing its secrets like never before, thanks to the recently inaugurated Vera Rubin Observatory in Chile—an ambitious initiative by the U.S. Department of Energy and the National Science Foundation. Equipped with some of the most powerful telescopes ever built, the observatory promises to collect more data about the cosmos than all previous astronomical efforts combined. “The Rubin Observatory will capture more information about our universe than… throughout history combined,” said Brian Stone, acting director of the NSF.
In just its first few hours of operation, the observatory discovered over 2,100 previously unknown asteroids—an astonishing feat that hints at the groundbreaking discoveries to come. Fittingly, this monumental scientific endeavor bears the name of Vera Rubin, the pioneering American Jewish astronomer whose revolutionary work on dark matter reshaped our understanding of the universe. Though her contributions were long overlooked, Rubin’s legacy now rises with the stars she once studied.
Vera Rubin was born in Philadelphia in 1928 and fondly remembered her upbringing in a warm, close-knit Jewish family. “My father, Pesach Kobchefski, was born in Vilna, Latvia,” she recalled. Her maternal grandmother, who hailed from Bessarabia, kept strictly kosher—a detail Vera remembered vividly.
From an early age, Vera was captivated by the mysteries of the natural world. “As a very young child, I was continually puzzled by the curious workings of the world,” she said. “As we drove home from… Bubba (Grandma in Yiddish) Cooper’s house, the bushes, trees and even distant hills passed behind us, but the moon sat steadily outside my window. How could the moon know that we were going home?”
Measuring spectra recorded on photographic plates at the Carnegie Institution’s Department of Terrestrial Magnetism in 1972.
When her father took a position with the Department of Agriculture, the family relocated to Washington, D.C. There, Vera shared a bedroom with her sister. “From my bed against the window, I had a clear view to the north sky,” she remembered. “Soon it was more interesting to watch the stars than to sleep. I started reading library books, thinking that if I read enough books I would ‘understand it all.’”
Her parents nurtured her growing passion for science. Together, she and her father built a homemade telescope. Meanwhile, her mother successfully convinced the local library to let young Vera check out “adult” science books—fueling a lifelong pursuit of understanding the universe.
Though Vera’s parents believed in her abilities, she encountered overt sexism in school during the 1940s. Her high school physics teacher openly dismissed the idea of women pursuing science, going so far as to mock female scientists in front of the class. When Vera proudly shared that she had been accepted to Vassar College on a scholarship, he offered a chilling piece of advice: “Stay away from science.”
At Vassar—then an all-women’s college—Vera stood out. She was the only student in her year to major in Astronomy. After graduating, she began applying to graduate programs. Princeton, which did not admit women at the time, refused to even acknowledge her application. Undeterred, Vera went on to earn a Master’s degree from Cornell, followed by a Ph.D. from Georgetown.
At Cornell, Vera focused her research on the velocities of distant galaxies—a critical piece of evidence supporting the Big Bang theory. This foundational idea holds that the entire universe burst into existence in a single moment, and galaxies are still racing outward at astonishing speeds, a cosmic echo of that moment of Creation.
Her thesis was so compelling that one of her professors offered to present it at an upcoming scientific conference—on the condition that he receive all the credit. Vera declined. Instead, she insisted on presenting the research herself.
It wasn’t an easy decision. By that time, Vera had married Bob Rubin, a young Navy officer introduced to her by her parents, and they had a baby at home. On top of that, she didn’t yet know how to drive. Even so, she managed to make it to the conference—only to be met with hostility. She was heckled by “many angry sounding men.”
One voice, however, stood out amid the skepticism: renowned Jewish German astrophysicist Martin Schwarzschild told her the research was “very interesting” and deserved further exploration.
The next day, The Washington Post ran a striking headline across its front page: “Young Mother Finds Center of Creation.” Vera’s work helped shift scientific consensus and brought the Big Bang theory closer to accepted fact.
Vera went on to have three more children while continuing her academic career as a professor at Georgetown University. In 1965, she began working at the Carnegie Institution of Washington, where she broke new ground by becoming the first woman permitted to conduct scientific research under her own name at the Mount Palomar Observatory in San Diego.
Using an image tube spectrograph on a telescope at Kitt Peak National Observatory.
There, she partnered with astronomer Kent Ford and delved deeper into the study of spiral galaxies—vast, rotating systems of stars. Together, they made a remarkable discovery: these galaxies were far more structurally cohesive than traditional physics would predict. Vera observed that stars on the outskirts of spiral galaxies were rotating just as quickly as those near the center. This defied expectations—according to Newtonian physics, the gravitational pull at the edges should be too weak to maintain such alignment. “What you see in a spiral galaxy is not what you get,” Vera famously remarked.
As she wrestled with this conundrum, Vera was reminded of earlier research by astrophysicist Fritz Zwicky. In 1933, Zwicky had studied the Coma galaxy cluster and noticed an unusually high gravitational force. Like Rubin, he observed that stars on the outer edges moved far faster than expected. Zwicky proposed that a mysterious, invisible substance—dunkle Materie, or “dark matter”—must be present, exerting gravitational force while remaining unseen.
Could the same unseen force Rubin and Ford had measured be the very phenomenon Zwicky had proposed decades earlier?
Their observations gave powerful momentum to the dark matter hypothesis. Vera calculated that dark matter must be about ten times more abundant than visible matter in the universe and that it exerts a gravitational pull across vast cosmic distances. For years, Rubin and Ford were widely considered strong contenders for the Nobel Prize. In 2015, many believed they would finally be honored with the Nobel Prize in Physics—but the award instead went to researchers studying neutrino oscillations. The decision sparked controversy, with some critics arguing that gender bias had once again denied Vera the recognition she so clearly deserved.
Vera and her husband Bob were lifelong members of a synagogue in Washington, D.C., and Vera consistently described herself as a religious Jew. In a 1996 interview, she reflected, “I’m Jewish, and so religion to me is a kind of moral code and a kind of history. I try to do my science in a moral way, and, I believe that, ideally, science should be looked upon as something that helps us understand our role in the universe.”
She firmly believed there was no contradiction between science and religion. For Vera, scientific discovery deepened—not diminished—her sense of wonder and her understanding of the world and her place within it.

Though celebrated as a pioneer of dark matter theory, Vera remained humble about the limits of human knowledge. “In a spiral galaxy, the ratio of dark-to-light matter is about a factor of 10,” she once remarked. “That’s probably a good number for the ratio of our ignorance to knowledge.”
One value Vera held above all was our shared responsibility to be decent, fair, and kind. In a 1996 lecture at Berkeley, she urged students: “I hope you will love your work as I love doing astronomy. I hope that you will fight injustice and discrimination in all its guises. I hope you will value diversity among your friends, among your colleagues, and… among the student body population. I hope that when you are in charge, you will do better than my generation has.”
Vera Rubin passed away in 2016 at the age of 88. Today, the observatory that bears her name is beginning to chart the most expansive view of the night sky ever recorded. Like Vera, we too can look to the stars—seeking not just knowledge, but meaning. Inspired by her legacy, may we carry forward her spirit of inquiry, and continue to marvel at the extraordinary wonders of creation.

I am just blown away by this brilliant, wonderful Jewish woman. I have to admit I was happy to know she was one of ours. I just marvel at the great things she accomplished. What a mind she has. Thank you for this wonderful opportunity to read this after just learning about her. There are no coincidences.
Thank you, but... “My father, Pesach Kobchefski, was born in Vilna, Latvia”. However Vilna (Vilnius) was (and is) in Litva (Lithuania), not Latvia.
A couple more things about Vera:
Vera Rubin also was the first to come up with the idea and proved that galaxies can collide to form bigger ones and disrupt the motions of stars within them. Pope John Paul II appointed her to the Pontifical Academy for Sciences (despite being Jewish)
I live and work with three basic assumptions.
There is no problem in science that can be solved by a man that cannot be solved by a woman. Worldwide, half of all brains are in women. We all need permission to do science, but for reasons that are deeply ingrained in history, this permission is more often given to men than to women.”
“It is well known that I am available twenty-four hours a day.to women astronomers.
Scientific knowledge and recognized academic power must be a matter of for women!!
And to sea the current regime in power and its war on science! Its de-funding of scientific research and government departments that aid people, including NOAA and NASA and its hatred of vaccines, global warming facts etc.... Gevalt!
Minor correction: SO, Vilna (Vilnius, and for a bit Vilno when the Polish occupied the city) is not in Lavia but in Lithuania.
New VERA RUBIN Quarter coin, for 2025
===============================
You will be reminded of her great discoveries, with this new coin.
"Seeing is believing" Mazel Tov !
Rubin advanced self promotion for decades after my father’s passing by assigning herself forced credit for Dark Matter, while feigning humility as a woman in the sciences primarily concerned with advancing that effort for women in the sciences. I continually corrected the public record after advising Rubin directly that I would correct any of her false public assertions regarding Dark Matter in the public arena. PBS Makers Women removed the segment, “Vera Rubin, Discoverer of Dark Matter,” the Poughkeepsie Journal printed a front page correction to false credit assigned to Rubin for Dark Matter, and Vassar College changed Rubin’s lecture title: “I left Vassar and Found Dark Matter.” Rubin the celebrated plagiarist and unwanted barnacle seeking credit for my father's work.
Give it up already, Barbarina!
Maybe she's right - how do you know she isn't?
We know that Barbarina is right simply by reading the article:
"In 1933, Zwicky had studied the Coma galaxy cluster and noticed an unusually high gravitational force.
LikeDECADES BEFORE Rubin, he observed that stars on the outer edges moved far faster than expected. Zwicky proposed that ...“dark matter”—must be present, exerting gravitational force while remaining unseen."What a bizarre slant the article puts on this. Obviously, Rubin wasn't the discoverer of dark matter. Why give her credit?
The article is in dire need of a re-write to be clear what, if anything, Rubin deserves credit for.
Ms. Zwicky - thank you for your comment. I hope this article honors both Dr. Rubin and your father by noting that Dr. Rubin's observations "gave powerful momentum" to your father's dark matter hypothesis.
It was both your father's initial groundbreaking observations and Dr. Rubin's later observations which convinced the scientific community of your father's hypothesis. As NASA currently notes on its website:
"Scientists first suspected dark matter’s existence over 80 years ago when Swiss-American astronomer Fritz Zwicky observed that galaxies in the Coma cluster.... Then in the 1970s, American astronomer Vera Rubin discovered the same type of problem.... Ever since these discoveries, scientists have been trying to piece together the puzzle using sparse clues."
Nice clarification.
Women such as Vera had obvious difficulties in being accepted among their male peers for many years. She raised a family and understood how religion and science were not incompatible. Her intelligence is multi-faceted. Thanks for the enlightening article.