Why Does the Word “Zionist” Still Exist?
2 min read
What exactly is the extent of the land promised to Abraham in Genesis 15:18-21? It doesn’t seem to be identical to the Land of Israel God later promised to Israel and outlined in Numbers 34.
Thank you for your perceptive observation. In fact, in Genesis God promised Abraham the land which was then inhabited by ten nations, spanning from the Euphrates River to the “River of Egypt,” which most commentators understand to be Wadi el-Arish, a wadi in the north-eastern Sinai Peninsula. Yet to the Children of Israel God many times mentions the land of the seven nations of Canaan (e.g. Deut. 7:1), not ten. Is this a smaller promise then the one originally made to Abraham?
The Midrash explains that lands of the first three of the original ten nations were given to other members of Abraham’s family. Specifically, the land of the Keinites was given to Esau’s descendants (the nation of Edom), the Kenizzites to Lot’s son Moab, and the Kadmonites to his son Ammon. (Those two nations were granted some of Abraham’s land in the merit that their father Lot did not betray Abraham to the king of Egypt when Abraham claimed Sarah was his sister (Genesis 12).) (Source: Bereishit Rabbah 44:23, 51:6. See Rashi to Genesis 15:19 and Deuteronomy 2:5.)
The Land of Edom roughly corresponds to the southern parts of modern Israel and Jordan, south of the Dead Sea. The lands of Ammon and Moab were to the east of the Jordan River, spanning across much of western Jordan, across from the Dead Sea (Moab) and further north.
As a result, the land promised to Israel later was smaller, corresponding to the borders described in Numbers 34. In fact, God specifically warned the Children of Israel not to touch the lands of those nations which were promised to them (Deut. 2:5,9,19).
This gift to the other nations, however, was temporary. In the Messianic Era Israel will be granted the entire ten lands. This is as Isaiah 11:14 states, “Edom and Moab will be the reach of their hands, and the Children of Ammon shall obey them.” See also Deut. 12:20, which refers to a much larger Land of Israel in the future, which the Midrash explains will occur when Israel will inherit the lands of the three nations (Sifri there).
→ Ask the Rabbi a Question ← Click here to comment on this article
Excellent assessment!! That includes where the River of Egypt is. I've seen some pastors equate the River of Egypt with the Nile River. which doesn't make sense to me seeing as the River of Egypt IS used as a border in describing Judah's allotment and from what I understand Judah did NOT have its border at the Nile. Very interesting about the three nations going to Esau, Moab, and Ammon. Had not heard that reasoning before, but it makes perfect sense seeing as Israel was not to go against Moab and Ammon in particular when Israel was coming into the land.
I agree with you, and it also explains why God was so indignant with Edom, Ammon, and Moab in the book of Jeremiah, specifically chapters 48-49. Their pagan idol worship and their collaboration with Nebuchadnezzar to bring down Judah and Israel amounted to a great betrayal of their semitic brothers the Jews.