Why I’m a 40+ Year Old Virgin

Advertisements
Advertisements
August 15, 2023

5 min read

FacebookTwitterLinkedInPrintFriendlyShare

I've been on hundreds of dates, I'm past 40, still single, and still a virgin. Here’s why.

My date, who'd recently become religious, was unburdening himself and talking about how difficult it was to be divorced and alone – totally not considering that throughout all the years he had been married, I had been alone.

I told him so and could see his brain racing, calculating, thinking…

“Wait a second. Didn’t you tell me you’ve been religious from birth?” he asked.

“Yes, I did,” I nodded.

“And you haven’t ever been married?”

“No.”

“I can’t believe that. You seem so put together!” His brows furrowed. “So you’ve never…?” he was clearly too shocked to finish his thought.

“No, I’ve never,” I said, knowing what he meant.

“Wow. You’re still a virgin?” He was incredulous. It didn’t occur to him that his date could be a virgin. He was floored.

I nodded.

“Even my daughter is no longer a virgin,” he said.

Oh, the things people say! Now it was my turn to be shocked and do some mental calculations. How old did he say his daughter was? Fifteen? Sixteen? I knew he had not always been religious and that his daughter was not. I knew the world out there had very different values, but I wasn’t prepared to hear this. Why would he share something so personal about his own child so soon? Was this a point of pride or shame for him? I honestly couldn’t tell. I was at a loss for words.

Then he dropped this charming line: “We could get a hotel room right now and I’ll show you what you’ve been missing!” His inappropriate comment showed just how agitated he was that I had missed out.

My goal is marriage. If a guy can easily get what he wants from a woman, with no commitment necessary, he is far less likely to commit.

As deprived or lonely as I felt, this was obviously not the way it was going to happen. I want a proposal from someone I truly know – not a proposition from someone I just met. I want to be married properly according to Jewish law. And as difficult as it may be, I still want to follow Judaism’s laws regarding sex, despite what the media drums into us.

Film and tv has the habit of taunting and deriding virgins. Whether it’s subtly as in the Donna character in 90210 who was known as the “virgin” for putting off sexual activity from high school to college, or more obviously, the film “The 40-Year-Old Virgin,” where the lead character is a nerd.

There’s a lot of truth to the well-known expression “Why buy a cow when the milk is free.” My goal is marriage. If a guy can easily get what he wants from a woman, with no commitment necessary, he is far less likely to commit. I agree with those who argue that in societies where women just “give it away”, marriage rates are lower. If the goal is marriage, there has to be a price.

I know how hurt I feel when guys initially act interested and then boom, they don’t. The emotional rollercoaster can take weeks for me to get over. And that’s without the intensity of physical intimacy.

Attraction had blinded me in the past. I paid more attention to what “feels” good than to figuring out what “is” good. The giddy feeling I’d get from a man’s attention often prevented me from truly assessing whether our relationship made sense in practical terms or for a long-term marriage. Fortunately, I’d come to my senses pretty quickly. I knew others who have wasted years on “feeling” good before they figured out that there never was any real compatibility or shared goals.

My emotional boundaries may have been breached and sometimes even my physical boundaries, but I had my red line that I adamantly refused to cross. And I’m grateful for that.

I want physical intimacy to be part of a bigger package, one that I hope will last forever.

My best relationships were those where we kept respectful boundaries and worked toward mutual goals. The guy “that got away” was never the one I had lusted after, though after a break up I may have felt that way. The guy “that truly got away” is the guy I shared values with, the guy who gradually became my friend, the guy I realized would have been a great father to my children and a great husband to me.

These days, I’m clear-eyed. I don’t want short term physical pleasure. I don’t want multiple partners. I don’t want to compare or contrast or “test-drive” partners. I want physical intimacy to be part of a bigger package, one that I hope will last forever. I want it to be special and holy, reserved only for a relationship that encompasses a couple’s full commitment to each other, to God and to a shared way of life.

When I “lose” my virginity, I want it to mean that I finally “found” my life partner.

Click here to comment on this article
guest
76 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Steven
Steven
5 months ago

Now I have bought Sarah's book I can wholeheartedly endorse it. She tells here story with great humor but it is also very moving and conveys a very important spiritual message without preaching. Her book affects the reader emotionally, while also entertaining them.

Casey
Casey
7 months ago

Good for you!! Too many people compromise and as a woman, I also understand your frustration. I also want to wait! Thank you for your honesty!

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
6 months ago
Reply to  Casey

Thank you for your comment and have a Shana Tova!

lar cotral
lar cotral
7 months ago

not to wax too poetically, but
maintaining one's virginity is like not losing the key
to one's safe deposit box, one's inner soul, one's generational link from past thousands of generations to future ones which is all in your hands. You should have great success in finding your match who will appreciate everything you represent and will forge a wonderous relationship in the future.
lot's of bracha and hazlacha!

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
6 months ago
Reply to  lar cotral

Thank you so much. Have a shana tova!

Gershom
Gershom
7 months ago

May G-D bless your spiritual desire - to serve Him without caving in - to the permissive societies moral standards.
If you've not already done so - consider this - when Abraham's servant went to find a wife for Isaac - he spoke to NO ONE - except G-D - so that - he got no conflicting advice on what to do. He ASKED G-D - for a SIGN - as to WHO - would be the appropriate match for Isaac. G-D granted it.
May you be blessed with an answer - like Eliezer was.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
6 months ago
Reply to  Gershom

Thank you so much! Have a shana tova!

Barbara Davis
Barbara Davis
7 months ago

My son is also a 40+ year-old virgin. How about a shidduch?! I'm joking. Seriously, my son would probably kill me if he saw this post. I still would love to make a connection between the two of you, even if it would have to be a long distance one.

Too bad you don't live in Houston. It's a great place to live! We have a large Jewish community. We are the most diverse city in the U.S. Last but not least, we have more start-ups here than anywhere else in the U.S., and the majority are by women.

I'm a writer and the publisher of Small Business Today Magazine and my son has a media production company.

I was a virgin when I got married and have always had a strong sense of self-worth. A relationship needs to be based on friendship first to have a solid, long-lasting marriage.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Barbara Davis

Hi Barbara,
Clearly there are many of us out there! You are so sweet and funny and yes I think your son would be mad. Lol!

Thank you for your comment and I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," and then let me know your thoughts. You can check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Esther
Esther
7 months ago

Ime glad you are strong in your views and stick to them. Do not give up . Standing for true and holy values is so rare nowadays. G_d bless you with a worthy partenaire and true hapiness

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Esther

Thank you Esther!

Steven
Steven
7 months ago

I am in two minds about your article. On the one hand, the fact that you are only want a marriage relationship is praiseworthy, but perhaps the fact you have never been in a physical relationship was not appropriate to share with the world at large?
You are obviously a very intelligent and eloquent person, and there is surely someone who would value you as a wife, but I think the emphasis placed on the physical aspect of relationships is misleading.
Obviously, it is an obligation on humanity to have children, and it is a physical pleasure, but it is a fleeting pleasure. Immediately afterwards, a man feels a kind of disgust comparable perhaps to that of the glutton after gulping down his meal. The real, lasting pleasures are those we get from our spiritual growth and these you have

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Steven

Thank you for your comment Steven.

My book, Unmatched goes into more depth about my journey. The physical aspect is a minor part. There's so much more to the story of dating with faith than that. I wrote it with two purposes in mind. To help singles feel validated and heard and to help others feel more empathy. From the letters I've received, I think my book has done just that. I hope that compensates for any inappropriateness. I also hide my face etc... and did my best to write modestly while telling the true story.

I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," and let me know your thoughts. I think the book will be eye-opening. Check out reviews and excerpts on unmatchedstory.com

I'm in your camp.
I'm in your camp.
7 months ago

Stick to your guns, lady. I hope you meet your beshert soon. And even if you never do, there are worse things than being single.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago

Thank you. Yes we often compare ourselves to those better off and express discontent or envy. But if we compare ourselves to those worse off, we'd express more gratitude. It's hard but I know I'm still fortunate in so many ways! You are right!

I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," and then let me know your thoughts. Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Michael Pearson
Michael Pearson
7 months ago

I'm so proud of you for waiting. Unfortunately, there are so few men that will respect women to the point of not touching until after marriage. Also, women run around showing off so much more than they should trying to get a man. I too am a man that prefers to wait for marriage. I was married for 32 years till my wife went to heaven. I totally agree with everything you said as it is so true and lines up with God's expectations for His people and His word. May the Lord bless you and keep you. Shalom

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago

Thank you for your comments Michael. That means a lot to me. So sorry for your loss! Did you lose her recently? Sorry.

I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," and then let me know your thoughts. Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Yosef
Yosef
8 months ago

Kudos to you for standing strong!

...and btw, your considered reasoning is but the 'icing on the cake'; your truest triumph is following Ratzon haBorei and maintaining your Kedushas Bas Yisrael! You are a credit to Am Yisrael; a devoted daughter of Avraham Avinu, refusing to bow to the values of the zeitgeist! Kol haKavod to you and all who stand with you, upholding the Torah of Hakadosh Boruch Hu against the contemporary vogue!

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Yosef

thank you Yosef. That means a lot to me. You are correct. The truest motivator is Ratzon Hashem! I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," about just that -- the struggle of dating with faith. If you do, then please let me know your thoughts!

Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Matt
Matt
8 months ago

Sarah, I appreciate your openness to talk about a subject that effects many people. However, I think you have lost perspective on relationship issues and have lost some ability to self-analyze.

Rather than discuss your "virginness" the more powerful discussion to ask is how an intelligent, successful woman, living in a place (NY) with more observant Jews than anywhere outside of Israel, is still unmarried (and wants to be?) has not found a mate by 40+.

Maybe you have a fear of commitment, of opening yourself up to hurt, or maybe you enjoy your life as it is? Only you have the power to try to understand why you are in the position you are in life and take responsibility for it and try to improve your situation - but only if that is truly your goal.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Matt

Hi Matt, Thank you for your comment. I wrote "Unmatched" precisely to answer questions such as yours. I hope you will take the time to read it and then let me know your thoughts. I think the book will be eye-opening. Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com Thank you, Sarah
p.s. i think the word you were looking for was "virginity" :-)... unfortunately, there are dozens of women in NYC in the same position as me.

Kim
Kim
8 months ago

Sarah, thank you. It is good to hear someone else with a history that parallels mine. I pray that everyone seeks righteousness.

Last edited 8 months ago by Kim
Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Kim

Thank you for your comment Kim. If our histories are parallel, then I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," it may resonate with you. Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Jay
Jay
8 months ago

I'm not surprised that you're a virgin. In fact, and please don't take this the wrong way. I am so proud of you.
I wished I had been stronger when I was younger. I am not a wham, bang thank you ma'am kind of man and move on to my next conquest.
Just because I am a man 61yrs old doesn't mean I jump in bed with the first woman who bats their eyes at me.
I don't just give myself to just anyone. Shalom, shalom.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Jay

Thank you for your comment, Jay. I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," and then let me know your thoughts. I think the book will be eye-opening. Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Last edited 7 months ago by Sarah Lavane
Rob
Rob
8 months ago

You go girl - יאשר כחך!

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Rob

Thank you Rob!

Nancy
Nancy
7 months ago
Reply to  Rob

I agree with you Rob. And, I am happy that I was able to read the Hebrew!!

John
John
8 months ago

I think you are a very wise person. Thank you for sharing.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  John

Thank you, John!

Shimon Kamenezky
Shimon Kamenezky
8 months ago

Parabens

John Dixon
John Dixon
8 months ago

The Lord bless you for your commitment to Him and His values.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  John Dixon

Thank you for your wishes, John! That means so much to me! Blessings to you as well!

Tom
Tom
8 months ago

Unfortunately time has passed her by as she is too old for children .

E.R
E.R
8 months ago
Reply to  Tom

Nah, what era are you living on? Women can have kids one way or another nowadays till their around 60.I wouldn't panic yet.

Jan
Jan
8 months ago
Reply to  Tom

Not true

Christina
Christina
7 months ago
Reply to  Jan

If she's healthy, she can have her very first child at 50 years young.

Linda Rivera
Linda Rivera
7 months ago
Reply to  Tom

Some women are scared about getting too old and losing their fertility. They do IVF and freeze their eggs, waiting until they hopefully get married at a future time.

Ben Blue
Ben Blue
8 months ago

Moralistic claptrap - prudishness at best.

Susan Krupman
Susan Krupman
8 months ago
Reply to  Ben Blue

Not at all. She's just sharing a different perspective than prevailing culture. You are the one being judgemental.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Susan Krupman

Thank you Susan!

yaakovashoshana
yaakovashoshana
8 months ago

I'm 60+ and still a virgin. I grew up in the 60s and 70s, and I attended a conservative church. I was a conscientious objector in the sexual revolution. Still am.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago

Thank you for your comment. Would love to read your book someday. Check out "Unmatched." It may resonate for you!

eli katzenstein
eli katzenstein
8 months ago

This women deserves a husband, who truly respect and appreciate her dedication and self sacrifice and high quality Jewish worldview.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago

Thank you so much Eli!

Rochelle Kaplan
Rochelle Kaplan
8 months ago

You posed a very important value that is sorely lacking among our youth. Parents need to be role models and not strive to be a friend.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago

Thank you Rochelle!

Phil
Phil
8 months ago

It’s so good to hear that there are others who seek purity. I’m 51, have had plenty of opportunities and heavy temptation to compromise myself with women in my life, but I don’t consider it a loss to have waited. People could judge all they’d like, but I want to honour G-d and the one person I plan to spend the rest of my life with.

Last edited 8 months ago by Phil
Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Phil

Glad to hear Phil!

I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," and then let me know your thoughts. I think the book may resonate with you.

Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com
Thank you

Last edited 7 months ago by Sarah Lavane
Martin
Martin
8 months ago

Sarah stick to your beliefs I’m now 82 married for 52 years. Once we became engaged is when we started full relationship. I was brought up semi religious not overly observant
Both daughters have divorced and married out
Tried online dating I
Eldest married twice. She has terrible taste in men, First was a slob the second finished due to domestic abuse.
Please G-d you’ll find a man worthy of you
Best wishes from UK

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Martin

Thank you Martin for that wonderful blessing.

I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," and then let me know your thoughts. I think the book will be eye-opening. Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Last edited 7 months ago by Sarah Lavane
Ricky
Ricky
8 months ago

When she says, "The giddy feeling I’d get from a man’s attention often prevented me from truly assessing whether our relationship made sense in practical terms or for a long-term marriage. Fortunately, I’d come to my senses pretty quickly. I knew others who have wasted years on “feeling” good before they figured out that there never was any real compatibility or shared goals," It makes me think she's not really in to marriage. What's that about, wasting years on feeling good?? You don't waste years feeling good, you enjoy them! And, if after many years together, you realize you have some differences, you try to work them out! And you try to stay together for whatever made you feel good. And you look back on those years, grateful to have had them, and hopefully have raised a family.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Ricky

Dear Ricky,

I think you may have misunderstood what I wrote above. I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," and then let me know your thoughts. I think the book will be eye-opening. Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Last edited 7 months ago by Sarah Lavane
Paul Brown
Paul Brown
8 months ago

well said and well written. To have such faith is a beacon to us all.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Paul Brown

Thank you Paul! That means a lot to me! I hope you will check out my memoir "Unmatched" on faith while dating.

Gershom
Gershom
8 months ago

Stick to your guns and May G-D help you and arrange an answer your heartfelt prayers for the perfect husband match.
Now looking for a wife I know what you're going through - and feel the same way.

Last edited 8 months ago by Gershom
Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Gershom

Thank you, Gershom. You too. Good luck. Maybe "Unmatched" will resonate with you. I've had plenty of male readers who have been able to relate to it.

Last edited 7 months ago by Sarah Lavane
Rivkah bat David
Rivkah bat David
8 months ago

Wonderful! Good for you! Keep on keeping on! From an 86 year old who didn't keep to all your values but I wish I had.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago

Thank you Rivkah. Would love to read YOUR book someday! 🙂 Please let me know your thoughts if you ever read "Unmatched." And thank you for your comment.

Last edited 7 months ago by Sarah Lavane
PC
PC
8 months ago

You are not alone, Sarah—there are millions that share your value of chastity: many Christians, virtually all Muslims and Hindus, and some Jews. So don’t listen to the secular media that promotes casual sex. Again: you are not alone!

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  PC

Thank you so much, PC. I hope "Unmatched" will help others realize that they too are not alone. Please let me know your thoughts if you ever read it.

Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com
Thank you, Sarah

David
David
8 months ago

Isnt what he was suggesting a terrible sin? Not just that she wanted the full package. Sorry, I dont understand this article.

Batia
Batia
8 months ago
Reply to  David

Of course it's a sin.

I appreciate that many people need a perspective like the one the author is sharing: that sex before marriage is not useful, that it doesn't serve you. Moreover, just by being a proud virgin, the author is showing people a different possibility.

However, I also think this explanation misses the bigger picture: Sex outside of marriage is demeaning and disgusting, an anathema. Why would a woman even chase such a thing?

I feel like women in less "Americanized" countries understand this intuitively. Whereas American women have been groomed by media and schooling to be "loose," to use clean language. It's sad, and sick. And now we're at the point of having to convince ppl that abstaining from sex before marriage is "also" a valid choice.

One Jew's thoughts
One Jew's thoughts
8 months ago
Reply to  David

It is (though there is still a difference to being with a married woman or man to man).

 

Now, there is a concept from the Talmudic rabbis of 'metoch shelo lishma ba lishma', that ever since the sin of the Tree of Knowledge, no person does the mitzvos/commandments solely for the sake of Heaven (which would be ideal); there is a certain amount of drive for personal pleasure or gain. (This, explains the Kli Yakar in Bereishis, is the reason we need to wear clothing.)

 

So, we always need some form of encouragement -- it is as the starter on a car (the allowed/mitzvah pleasures, of course), then one can focus on doing for the sake of Heaven/mitzvah.

Let us strengthen in faith that one will have whatever one needs at every age and stage, and God will give more than one can imagine!!!

Nancy
Nancy
8 months ago

This was a very thought provoking article. However, we need to retire the expression about the cow and the milk. It is beyond sexist.

Ron T
Ron T
8 months ago
Reply to  Nancy

How is it sexist? It says that people aren’t going to buy a product if they can get it for free. I’m 67. I got married because that used to be the only respectable way to have a family. Now there are no taboos or shame.
Sarah must be bad at picking dates if she can’t find a decent man by 40.

Ra'anan
Ra'anan
8 months ago
Reply to  Ron T

And you must be bad at ona-ath devarim to make such a comment.

David
David
8 months ago
Reply to  Ron T

That's a very presumptuous assumption. Maybe there are more lost men out there today then what it used to be 30/40 years ago? Values have been trashed during these last years that there is no wonder we have people with their heads on with the right values that refuse to abduct or lower themselves to such depravation because by doing so it would mean give up and reinforcing today's "modern world" unfortunate depraved philosophy. It is very easy to judge but what about empathy and appreciating the right and holly values of Moses Law?
Should we put to shame someone that refuses to eat non kosher meat or drink non kosher wine where not available? Isn't womanizing to look at a female only for the purpose of pleasure?

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  David

Thank you David! I wrote Unmatched precisely because I was tired of all these assumptions. Though it's a memoir, it does shed light on the experience that many go through. I hope you will take the time to read it and then let me know your thoughts. I think the book will be eye-opening for many.

Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com Thank you, Sarah

E.R
E.R
8 months ago
Reply to  Ron T

I'm laughing bc you are insinuating the market is just chocablok with great men.
It isn't.
At all.

Rob
Rob
8 months ago
Reply to  Ron T

Nothing sexist about it! And... feminism & elastic ethics have made it very difficult for good ladies to find a mensch/gem!

Nancy
Nancy
8 months ago
Reply to  Rob

It is sexist because a woman is not a "product." Neither is a man. This is not Madison Avenue. Does anyone tell a man not to buy the cow if he can get the milk for free? Ask yourselves that question. With that said, I truly respect Sarah's viewpoint.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Nancy

Hi Nancy, Logically there's no need to discourage a man from doing something he's already not doing. But perhaps I could've found a better way to get the point across today. I hope you check out "Unmatched." It's a thought provoking book. Thank you for sharing your comments.

Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Thanks,
Sarah

Last edited 7 months ago by Sarah Lavane
Nancy
Nancy
7 months ago
Reply to  Sarah Lavane

I will check out Unmatched. Btw--I truly respect your viewpoint. I was bothered by what your date said about his daughter. My son does not even want me to talk about how intelligent he is. 🙂 This man crossed a HUGE boundary.

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Nancy

Thank you Nancy... I'm glad you came back to see my response! And I appreciate all the comments.

Kids never do like when their mothers talk about them! I'm sure that daughter would be mortified.

Please do let me know what you think of the book if you read it. You can always reach me through my website unmatchedstory.com

Sarah Lavane
Sarah Lavane
7 months ago
Reply to  Ron T

Dear Ron T, I hope you will take the time to read "Unmatched," I wrote it for anyone who ever jumped to conclusions such as "Sarah must be bad at picking dates if she can’t find a decent man by 40."

I hope you will take the time to read it and then let me know your thoughts. I think the book will be eye-opening. Check out reviews and excerpts on amazon or at unmatchedstory.com

Thank you, Sarah

EXPLORE
LEARN
MORE
Explore
Learn
Resources
Next Steps
About
Donate
Menu
Languages
Menu
Social
.