Like What You Read? Give Jews around the
world the chance to experience engaging Jewish wisdom with more articles and videos on Aish. As a
nonprofit organization it's your support that keeps us going. Thanks so much!
Our bodies do define us whether Orthodox Judaism agrees with it or not. Otherwise, women wouldn't be required to shave their heads to be Tsneas, etc. It's rather hard-hearted to tell a burn victim they can't have a tattoo to help restore their eyebrows, etc. Totally discounts the psychological aspect of healing and reclaiming their identity.
I don't want one because I don't trust the ink and how it would affect the liver. And it seems disrespectful to Holocaust victims.
Rabbi Yisroel Reisman gave a great talk on tattooing many years ago. Part of his talk addressed tattoo's we receive when a colonoscopy is preformed, and the doctor marks a suspect area. Also discussed was when a lady who has cancer and loses all hair including eyebrows and asks a question if she is allowed to have eyebrows tattooed to replace the ones she has lost. Rabbi Reisman gives a Navi Shiur every motzei Shabbos and he also wrote an authoritative book on Ribbis.
Last edited 1 year ago by Renee L.
Bob Mandel
1 year ago
God may have allowed tattoos as in Isaiah 44:5 saying, "One shall say, “I am GOD’s,” Another shall use the name of “Jacob,” Another shall mark his arm “of GOD” And adopt the name of “Israel.”
Your article references not to make gashes or marks on your body for the death of people.
According to the ORTHODOX ARTSCROLL JEWISH TEXT - you've MISTRANSLATED/MISQUOTED Isaiah 44;5. As it says: "......one will sign his ALLEGIANCE TO HASHEM (G-D).". NOT to be interpreted that - G-D - may have allowed tattoos.
Who authorized the Orthodox Artscroll Jewish Text to interpret the words of G-d's Torah? Can you read the Hebrew text?
The Hebrew verb here is "yichtom" (יִחְתֹּם), meaning "shall seal" or "to mark." This suggests a permanent marking or inscription, not simply a verbal declaration. The phrase "The Lord's" indicates a declaration of ownership or devotion to God. The action of writing or marking the hand implies a visible and personal sign of allegiance to God.
Bob - The Artscroll - is one of the PREMIER TRUSTED & ACCEPTED ORTHODOX TANACHS - IN both HEBREW & IVRIT. It follows LETTER FOR LETTER - The HALACHIC TORAH Scrolls. Unfortunately - Isaiah - isn't part of the G-D's Written Torah & often translations - can be vague. Yes - I can read in both languages - & if I have a word I don't understand - I consult the dictionary - or a rabbi. Though the Hebrew word - "Yichtom" may be correct - IT STILL DOES NOT SPECIFY TATTOOING! Common sense - should tell you that - Isaiah a HIGHLY RESPECTED PROPHETS words - would have instructed that we are to KEEP G-D's WRITTEN TORAH COMMAND - NOT - to PUT A TATTOO on oneself & not inferred it's OK - tattooing oneself.
Noah
1 year ago
The guy would rather mark up his body with toxic permanent ink rather than just wear a kippah or tzitzit, which he should be doing anyway. Makes total sense.
Marcia
1 year ago
Very good modern day explanation of getting a tattoo. I know it’s considered body art, but it’s still hard to accept as a Jew.
wondering why you can't answer a question without becoming belligerent. is that in the Torah, too?
Frank Adam
1 year ago
Jews evidently CAN get themselves tatooed.
The question is really whether they MAY do such a thing.
Gershom
1 year ago
One of the concerns I have is that: we ARE TAUGHT BY RABBIS - don't go to a NON-KOSHER place to eat - EVEN JUST A SALAD - WITH RELIGIOUS CLOTHING SHOWING! - As it may cause another Jew - to think the place is Kosher. ESPECIALLY PROBLEMATIC - are JEWS - who NOW - are OPENLY WEARING - the signs/symbols - that THEY ARE RELIGIOUS - AND - FLAUNTING THEIR UNCOVERED TATTOOS. When - YOUNG CHILDREN & UNAFFILIATED JEWS - see JEWS WITH UNCOVERED TATTOO'S - they think it MUST BE OK - THAT'S A RELIGIOUS JEW.
Our bodies do define us whether Orthodox Judaism agrees with it or not. Otherwise, women wouldn't be required to shave their heads to be Tsneas, etc. It's rather hard-hearted to tell a burn victim they can't have a tattoo to help restore their eyebrows, etc. Totally discounts the psychological aspect of healing and reclaiming their identity.
I don't want one because I don't trust the ink and how it would affect the liver. And it seems disrespectful to Holocaust victims.
NO
https://aish.com/judaism-and-tattoos/
Rabbi Yisroel Reisman gave a great talk on tattooing many years ago. Part of his talk addressed tattoo's we receive when a colonoscopy is preformed, and the doctor marks a suspect area. Also discussed was when a lady who has cancer and loses all hair including eyebrows and asks a question if she is allowed to have eyebrows tattooed to replace the ones she has lost. Rabbi Reisman gives a Navi Shiur every motzei Shabbos and he also wrote an authoritative book on Ribbis.
God may have allowed tattoos as in Isaiah 44:5 saying, "One shall say, “I am GOD’s,” Another shall use the name of “Jacob,” Another shall mark his arm “of GOD” And adopt the name of “Israel.”
Your article references not to make gashes or marks on your body for the death of people.
According to the ORTHODOX ARTSCROLL JEWISH TEXT - you've MISTRANSLATED/MISQUOTED Isaiah 44;5. As it says: "......one will sign his ALLEGIANCE TO HASHEM (G-D).". NOT to be interpreted that - G-D - may have allowed tattoos.
Who authorized the Orthodox Artscroll Jewish Text to interpret the words of G-d's Torah? Can you read the Hebrew text?
The Hebrew verb here is "yichtom" (יִחְתֹּם), meaning "shall seal" or "to mark." This suggests a permanent marking or inscription, not simply a verbal declaration. The phrase "The Lord's" indicates a declaration of ownership or devotion to God. The action of writing or marking the hand implies a visible and personal sign of allegiance to God.
This is according to G-d's unchangeable Torah.
Bob - The Artscroll - is one of the PREMIER TRUSTED & ACCEPTED ORTHODOX TANACHS - IN both HEBREW & IVRIT. It follows LETTER FOR LETTER - The HALACHIC TORAH Scrolls. Unfortunately - Isaiah - isn't part of the G-D's Written Torah & often translations - can be vague. Yes - I can read in both languages - & if I have a word I don't understand - I consult the dictionary - or a rabbi. Though the Hebrew word - "Yichtom" may be correct - IT STILL DOES NOT SPECIFY TATTOOING! Common sense - should tell you that - Isaiah a HIGHLY RESPECTED PROPHETS words - would have instructed that we are to KEEP G-D's WRITTEN TORAH COMMAND - NOT - to PUT A TATTOO on oneself & not inferred it's OK - tattooing oneself.
The guy would rather mark up his body with toxic permanent ink rather than just wear a kippah or tzitzit, which he should be doing anyway. Makes total sense.
Very good modern day explanation of getting a tattoo. I know it’s considered body art, but it’s still hard to accept as a Jew.
It's not a "hard concept." It is a violation of the mitzvah. Period.
Grow up.
wondering why you can't answer a question without becoming belligerent. is that in the Torah, too?
Jews evidently CAN get themselves tatooed.
The question is really whether they MAY do such a thing.
One of the concerns I have is that: we ARE TAUGHT BY RABBIS - don't go to a NON-KOSHER place to eat - EVEN JUST A SALAD - WITH RELIGIOUS CLOTHING SHOWING! - As it may cause another Jew - to think the place is Kosher. ESPECIALLY PROBLEMATIC - are JEWS - who NOW - are OPENLY WEARING - the signs/symbols - that THEY ARE RELIGIOUS - AND - FLAUNTING THEIR UNCOVERED TATTOOS. When - YOUNG CHILDREN & UNAFFILIATED JEWS - see JEWS WITH UNCOVERED TATTOO'S - they think it MUST BE OK - THAT'S A RELIGIOUS JEW.