A History Lesson on Tucker Carlson for Vice President J.D. Vance

Advertisements
Advertisements
September 22, 2026

5 min read

FacebookLinkedInXPrintFriendlyShare

J.D. Vance won't criticize his friend Tucker Carlson. A 1930s radio priest's story shows exactly why that's a mistake.

Tucker Carlson can rightfully be identified as one of those most responsible for normalizing antisemitism in America today. He regularly uses his platform of over 30 million listeners to promote conspiracy theories and falsehoods against Israel and Jews.

Among his more shocking statements:

  • In a February 2026 episode, Carlson claimed that Israel is “the most violent country in the world by far per capita.”
  • In a March 2026 episode, he observed, ‘Oh, the dancing Israelis. They did it. Israel had foreknowledge of 9/11.’ There were text messages sent to Israel, warning of 9/11. All true, by the way.”
  • In a May 2026 New York Times interview, Carlson claimed the Iraq War was itself a “product” of “Israel's interests above America's interests.” He described President Trump as a “hostage” under Netanyahu’s “total control” and called his relationship with the Israeli prime minister one of "slavery."

Carlson hosts antisemites and, using a "Just Asking" approach, lets his guests make antisemitic statements. He then defends himself by saying he didn't say anything. For example, he hosted white supremacist Nick Fuentes in October 2025. On the show, Fuentes claimed "organized Jewry" controls the world. Fuentes later posted a video saying, “Do us all a favor. We are done with the Jewish oligarchy. We are done with the slavish surrender to Israel, the wars, the foreign aid, the policing of antisemitism, the Holocaust religion and propaganda.” Carlson's response when questioned was to brush off Fuentes' comments, since he's "just a kid" who says "naughty things."

In light of Carlson’s dangerous message and enormous audience, Vice President J.D. Vance's refusal to call out Tucker Carlson for his bigotry is concerning. Vance’s statement, when questioned about Tucker Carlson, that “I’m not going to play the game where I throw friends under the bus because I have political disagreements with them," might be a good response on the playground, but for a leading politician to say that is downright dangerous.

J.D. Vance would do well to learn a lesson from another antisemite with a big audience, Father Coughlin.

The First Lesson: The Radio Priest’s Influence

Father Coughlin was a Catholic priest and one of the first public figures to see the power of radio broadcasts to influence others. In the 1930s, millions tuned in to his broadcast every Sunday. Like Carlson, his inflammatory remarks often drew criticism. When CBS asked him to tone down his remarks, he devoted the next episode to criticizing CBS for censorship, which only increased his audience. When CBS cut his contract, Coughlin started his own network, just as Carlson did after leaving Fox.

Father Coughlin

With his network now uncensored, Coughlin had the freedom to say anything he wanted. If he suggested it, Congress could be flooded with letters and telegrams on any issue. Many viewed him as America's most persuasive person.

As an antisemite, he used his platform to spread his ideas. He blamed Jews for communism and justified the Nazis for Kristallnacht, since that was what was needed to fight communism. As Carlson does regarding Iran, Coughlin accused Jews of planning World War II. More broadly, Coughlin strongly opposed America getting involved in World War II. As a public figure with a large audience and disproportionate influence, his isolationist policy had a strong impact on American opinion, keeping America out of the war until after Pearl Harbor.

Father Coughlin used his platform to blame Jews for communism, justified the Nazis for Kristallnacht and accused Jews of planning World War II.

The first lesson JD Vance can learn from Coughlin is that bigots with an audience can cause serious damage. Although Carlson defended himself after a controversial interview with Nick Fuentes by saying “he has no power except his words,” history shows words are powerful. Coughlin's words promoted antisemitic and isolationist policies that allowed the Holocaust to continue, and Carlson’s rhetoric today encourages antisemitism across America. A potential future President cannot keep a friend whose rhetoric hurts innocent people.

Feeding the Crocodile

Initially, Father Coughlin strongly supported President Roosevelt. He saw Roosevelt as the country’s economic savior. Roosevelt welcomed the popular priest's support and worked to build their relationship. Coughlin was proud of his connection to the President and believed he could influence New Deal policies.

Yet when Coughlin felt Roosevelt's policies were not strong enough, he reversed his support and began to criticize the President vehemently. Similar to Carlson’s approach to President Trump, Coughlin claimed the President was controlled by Wall Street and Jewish conspirators.

Bigots do not make good friends or political supporters.

Which brings us to the second lesson Vice President Vance can learn from history: Sir Winston Churchill said, “Appeasement is feeding the crocodile, hoping he will eat you last.” Not a very wise policy.

History has shown that bigots do not make good friends or political supporters. It is likely only a matter of time before Tucker Carlson throws J.D. Vance under the bus, as he did with President Trump.

If J.D. Vance truly cares about antisemitism and is opposed to bigotry and hatred, then the time has come for him to unequivocally call out Tucker Carlson and stand with those on the right side of history.

Click here to comment on this article
guest
57 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Ingie Danilewitz
Ingie Danilewitz
1 month ago

Outstanding article! Thank you for having the courage to speak the truth. Personally, I find JD Vance’s response to be nefarious, to say the very least!
Who wants to be friends with a Hitler? Only someone who covertly supports his doctrines and is complicit in his evil.

Gershom
Gershom
1 month ago

These stories about people like Carlson - remind me of the story of Balak - in G-D's Torah. Though Balak - knew that Bilaam - had contact with G-D - & he had power(s) - to make blessings. When Bilaam came to Balak - he told him - he could only tell him what G-D told him to say. However - no matter what Bilaam told him what G-D said - about Israel being BLESSED. He rejected that - & tried continually- to get Bilaam- to look at it from another point - as it wasn't the answer he wanted to hear. Still today - no matter what credible & authenticated evidence about Israel's history is presented by credible authenticated sources. These people reject it - as it's not what they want to hear. We Jews - IGNORE WHAT G-D said He'd do to us for - treating Him Casually.

Aviel
Aviel
1 month ago

As an American with a large audience Carlson can say what he thinks. Unlike in the 1930s when Father Coughlin had a huge audience and Jews were almost powerless as proven by the holocaust, Israel today has a strong economy , strong army and as a last resort nuclear weapons. That's not saying it's not uncomfortable for Jews in galut who stand with Israel in their war on terror, but thank God for the change. It bothers Carldon and others that a huge nation, the USA is partnering in a military sharing pact with tiny Israel but the strategic benefits to both sides are there or Trump wouldn't do it. Same goes for the decision to attack Iran. At least that's how I see it. I hope the near future will prove my point.

NoName4U
NoName4U
1 month ago

Carlson would have made a 'good' Nazi. His rhetoric is dangerous, and he needs to be strongly and vocally opposed by anyone with a good head on their shoulders.

Bina
Bina
1 month ago

Shame on Tucker and his evil actions. Shame on all his enablers.

Judy
Judy
1 month ago

Vance is ruining is chances for being president for not denouncing , Tucker Carlson and also not denouncing anti semitism these two factors will ruin his chances of becoming president, he is not catering to the regular people but quacks like his friend Tucker Carlson, and most people wouldn't like it

RACHEL
RACHEL
1 month ago
Reply to  Judy

Sadly, Vance is the current frontrunner for the Republican nomination, and Marco Rubio has hinted he will not run in 2028.

Judy
Judy
1 month ago
Reply to  RACHEL

That is in fact very sad for Jews and Israel

Eta Kushner
Eta Kushner
1 month ago

"If J.D. Vance truly cares about antisemitism..." Except, obviously he does not.

Sam
Sam
1 month ago

Tucker also spread conspiracy theories against Chabad, including blaming them for starting the war against Iran to build the Third Temple. He only stopped when threatened with mass lawsuits.

RACHEL
RACHEL
1 month ago

Can you imagine if G-d forbid our choice in 2028 is between AOC and Vance???

Bina
Bina
1 month ago
Reply to  RACHEL

That would be a nightmare but I would definitely pick VANCE

Sam
Sam
1 month ago
Reply to  RACHEL

BH No

Aviel
Aviel
1 month ago
Reply to  RACHEL

That could be a message that the time make Aliya has come.

Geri Kushner
Geri Kushner
1 month ago

How to send to Vsnce.

Sam
Sam
1 month ago
Reply to  Geri Kushner

The more its spread the more likely he sees it

Linda Goudsmit
Linda Goudsmit
1 month ago

A history lesson? This article naively assumes that J.D. Vance does not agree with Tucker Carlson! If J.D. Vance did not agree with Carlson he would have simply said so––but he didn’t. Actions speak much louder than words and, personally, I think J.D. Vance’s silence is dispositive. Vance is not fit to be president.

Yitzchak Rubin
Yitzchak Rubin
1 month ago

I totally agree with you. The article is "spot on". I grew up hearing about Father Coughlin as well as the Stalinists in the US Communist Party who supported Hitler after the Hitler-Stalin pact. I thank Hashem that Trump has a Jewish son-in-law who he seems to like and trust. Enough said.

Orrin
Orrin
1 month ago

I suspect that for most people, hatred of Jews is a problem only for Jews.

RACHEL
RACHEL
1 month ago
Reply to  Orrin

True. But there are millions of pro-Israel Christian Zionists who hate Tucker Carlson and are now questioning JD Vance's credentials to be President.

Ruth Broch
Ruth Broch
1 month ago
Reply to  RACHEL

I will never, ever vote for Vance.If he is the Republican candidate in 2028, I will write in either Rubio or Cruz.

nina kotek
nina kotek
1 month ago
Reply to  Ruth Broch

I agree about Rubio and Cruz, but let's see who the Democrat is before we start wasting our vote.

Judy
Judy
1 month ago
Reply to  Orrin

Not really, when they start up with Jews then the everyone else is in danger, it starts with the Jews and ends with everyone else, during the Holocaust it started with Jews and then everyone else was targeted, Jews are we like the canary in the coalmine when the canary is in danger everyone else is too

Mickey Owens
Mickey Owens
1 month ago

I am hoping that Marco Rubio runs for president. He is a fair minded person, with a fine grip on international policies.
I am afraid that J D Vance has forgotten his own background (of the underdog). Rubio remembers the trauma of Cuba and what that implies. He has the ability to understand what tyranny feels like.
Unfortunately, if Vance is the choice for president, and considering the alternative, I will still sadly vote for him.

rje
rje
1 month ago
Reply to  Mickey Owens

Perhaps you, and I as well, sometimes vote for the party, not the person.

Dvirah
Dvirah
1 month ago
Reply to  Mickey Owens

Why not look for a viable independent? I used to do that whenever I couldn’t in conscience vote for a major party candidate.
In Israel there’s a blank ballot that one can use. In the USA there isn’t, so voting for an independent that one can respect is the equivalent.

Aviel
Aviel
1 month ago
Reply to  Dvirah

Good option in principle but in reality a wasted vote. There is most always a choice even if it's the lesser of two evils

Geri Kushner
Geri Kushner
1 month ago
Reply to  Mickey Owens

💯%. Marco 2028

Graham
Graham
1 month ago
Reply to  Geri Kushner

Polo?

Judy
Judy
1 month ago
Reply to  Geri Kushner

I hope that comment would be true

JUDITH SVARC
JUDITH SVARC
1 month ago

Very true. I'm very disturbed (to say the least) with JD Vance's stance about Carlson. At the least he should vehemently reject his anti-semitism. Not good.

Lauren Blatt
Lauren Blatt
1 month ago

What makes you think that JD Vance isn’t an anti Semite !

Bubbelove
Bubbelove
1 month ago
Reply to  Lauren Blatt

In my opinion I am certain that Vance is in deed and anti-Semite and anti-Israel. Don't forget one is judged by the company you keep - and defend!

Judy
Judy
1 month ago
Reply to  Lauren Blatt

You know a person by the friends he keeps

Daniel
Daniel
2 months ago

Really good comparison to Father Coughlin. He like Carlson, did not start with his antisemitic rhetoric until the late thirties when the Nazis really publicized and justified their antisemitism with their propaganda tools. He, like Carlson, switched to antisemitism when he felt it was more popular. Both of them frame their antisemitism within a Catholic framework. It is really eerie how similar they both are. Coughlin's downfall was a threat of excommunication from the Church. There is no institution today that can limit Carlson. Obama had his Reverend Wright, and now Vance has Carlson. I voted for Trump in 2024, but will not vote Vance, unless he puts his foot down about Carlson.

Sam
Sam
2 months ago
Reply to  Daniel

Ditto

Bubbelove
Bubbelove
1 month ago
Reply to  Daniel

I believe it would be too late for Vance to redeem himself, but I don't think he wants that. He will never get my vote.

Ruth Broch
Ruth Broch
1 month ago
Reply to  Daniel

I won't vote for him no matter what he now or in the future does. He IS a Jew and Israel hater. Period.

nina kotek
nina kotek
1 month ago
Reply to  Ruth Broch

Just wait and see what the Democrats come up with.

Sam
Sam
1 month ago
Reply to  nina kotek

AOC

RACHEL
RACHEL
2 months ago

“Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” – George Santayana, The Life of Reason, 1905.

Karen Ess
Karen Ess
2 months ago

Vance is also an antisemite, otherwise he would confront Carlson. Birds of a feather.

RACHEL
RACHEL
2 months ago
Reply to  Karen Ess

He is an opportunist not an anti-Semite

Bubbelove
Bubbelove
1 month ago
Reply to  RACHEL

Rachel - I disagree with you. He is definitely an anti-Semite and anti-Israel. If you look carefully you will see it!

Gord
Gord
1 month ago
Reply to  RACHEL

How about both

Sam
Sam
2 months ago

Wow! Great analysis and history

Ephraim
Ephraim
2 months ago

Tucker Qatarlson is a raging out of control Nazi, a true genocidal Jew hater. Anyone allied with him obviously supports his views, and that includes Vance. I would NEVER vote for Vance, because it is obvious to me that he actually does accept Qatarlson's views, all of his public statements bear this out.

Max
Max
2 months ago

Good article with valid points. However, conflating being anti-Israel with antisemitism is not a given. They may well overlap or often be products of one another, but not always, and we shouldn't fear the intellectual honesty to see and say that.

Ephraim
Ephraim
2 months ago
Reply to  Max

If you are anti-Israel you are an antisemite. Not for criticizing Israel, that is no problem. Except NO ONE criticizes Israel, they demonize it, lie about it, and rabble rouse it into antisemitism regardless of the purported purpose. Objectively, Israel is one of the most moral countries on the face of the earth. Despite facing the kind of vicious genocidal Jew hatred from all quarters that no other country has ever faced, Israel conducts itself on the highest level from a moral standpoint. Those who refuse to see the facts are Nazis, like Coughlin, like Qatarlson, and their followers.

Elaine Bouranis
Elaine Bouranis
2 months ago
Reply to  Ephraim

Amen. I wholeheartedly agree.

Eli
Eli
2 months ago
Reply to  Max

Intellectual honesty would dictate that while anti-Semitism and anti-zionism don't have to overlap in theory, in practice they almost always do. Like Coughlin, Carlson is a classic anti-semite. Besides the Israel Lobby, he also has blamed Chabad, a religious organization, for the Iran War. It would be simpler, not to mention honest, if he just admitted he hates Jews.

Judy
Judy
1 month ago
Reply to  Eli

Being anti zionist= anti Semitic

Victoria Fairman
Victoria Fairman
2 months ago
Reply to  Max

I have yet to see an “anti-Israel” person who is not antiSemitic.
Israel is the Jew of the world. If you oppose the existence of only Jewish country in the world, you are a Jew hater. Israel is not an idea — it is here. Is it ok to wish half the world’s Jews dead or scattered to the ends of the earth?

Kevin
Kevin
2 months ago

How about anti-Netanyahu? That next election will be very close. Lots of us who love Israel and embrace the tenets of Judaism can also despise what the current gov't is Israel has been doing.

Lenny
Lenny
1 month ago
Reply to  Kevin

What have they been doing - trying to defend the Jews against anti-semites and terrorists? Netanyahu has (many) problems and I also put blame on him for October 7th, but NOT for the country's response to same. No other Prime Minister would have done it any differently. And unfortunately, I do not see anyone else with the type of wherewithall to deal with the Americans and President Trump that Netanyahu has. Anybody else will be run over by the U.S. President. That's not what Israel needs right now.

Dvirah
Dvirah
1 month ago
Reply to  Kevin

Nothing wrong there unless you use Netanyahu as a prop to demonize all Israelis, which so many do.
Also you should specify the actual policies that you disagree with. “What the government has been doing” is too broad a statement and, as the saying goes, will throw out the baby with the bathwater.

Judy
Judy
1 month ago

You are absolutely right

EXPLORE
LEARN
MORE
Explore
Learn
Resources
Next Steps
About
Donate
Menu
Languages
Menu
Social
.