> Family > Parenting

Where did grandma go when she died?

May 9, 2009 | by Rabbi Dr. Jerry Lob

Q: Where did grandma go when she died?

Q: Where did grandma go when she died?

A: When a child asks a question that is filled with pain,
it needs to be answered on two levels.

1) The first level is a direct response to the literal
question: Where is grandma now? The second level is more subtle and requires
understanding of what really is the child's unspoken concern.

Where is grandma now?

This question should be answered in a straightforward way
in accordance with Jewish teachings.

When God created human beings, He used earth to form the
bodies, but He also gave us something more. He shared of Himself with us, and
this piece of God within us is called the soul.

Life is body and soul working in harmony; death is their

The body returns to earth and the soul moves closer to

You can tell your child that while the soul is invisible,
it's still real. It is the essence of grandma and it never dies; it is eternal,
like God Himself. This means that grandma's essence is still alive but she can't
be seen.

Judaism teaches that deceased grandparents are present at
the wedding ceremony of their descendents. So grandma is aware of her family
still and will put in "a good word" for the ones she loves. And of
course, love never dies.

The second level, as noted above, is much more subtle. Oftentimes children
ask one question but are really asking something very different. You as parents
are challenged to look beyond the spoken words. What is your child asking? Or
what is your child asking for?

Is your daughter terribly afraid that you will die, or
others or she herself. If so, she needs hugs and reassurance that no one else
is dying now. Is your son in pain, in mourning? Is he angry at grandma for
leaving him, for abandoning him and not coming to his Bar Mitzvah. Is he
furious with God for taking his grandma or with you for letting her die?

Remember, pain and emotions in general don't need to be
rational. Is your child depressed, confused or afraid, or all
of the above? It's important that you talk with him/her and show that you're open
to all questions and to any emotional response on your child's part, including
confusion, fear, sadness, anger, etc. If your child would rather not talk,
encourage him to write about grandma and his feelings. Sharing your feelings
about your sadness can be helpful as well.

Your child needs to know that his feelings are okay, that
the pain will pass one day, and that his grandma still loves him, even if he is
angry at her. The same is true for God.


Leave a Reply

🤯 ⇐ That's you after reading our weekly email.

Our weekly email is chock full of interesting and relevant insights into Jewish history, food, philosophy, current events, holidays and more.
Sign up now. Impress your friends with how much you know.
We will never share your email address and you can unsubscribe in a single click.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram