In Poland, Even Winnie-the-Pooh Has a Holocaust Story


13 min read
14 min read
14 min read
5 min read
8 min read
The impact of monotheism on our daily lives.
Does God have anything to do with your finding a parking space? A job? An apartment? A spouse? And if you find any of these, does God have anything to do with your parked car getting scratched, your new boss having a temper, your apartment spouting a leak, or your spouse overspending or scrimping?
Are there domains ruled by God, such as tornadoes and earthquakes, and other domains, such as our daily lives, where God holds no sway?
Judaism propounds an idea that is as radical today as it was millennia ago: that there is one and only one operative force in the universe and that is God. In ancient times, that meant that instead of various deities of the sea, land, winds, etc., each with its own domain, there was only one God who ruled every place and everything. In our times, Jewish monotheism means that there is one ultimate power that directs and controls all that happens everywhere.
From a Jewish perspective, believing that the ultimate cause of losing your job is economic forces is as spurious as believing that the cause of thunder storms is Zeus.
The very job description of God is that God is the one who is in complete control, who runs the universe, from the nuclear fusion inside stars to your finding a parking space. The Bible tells us not to believe in “Elohim aherim.” The phrase is usually translated as “other gods” but it actually means “other forces.” From a Jewish point of view, believing that the ultimate cause of your losing your job is economic forces is as spurious as believing that the cause of thunder storms is Zeus. There is only one ultimate power behind everything, and that is God.
And God’s domain is not limited to cosmic processes. God is involved in the nitty-gritty. Indeed, this is how God introduced Himself to the entire Israelite nation at Mt. Sinai. The first of the Ten Commandments is: “I am the Lord your God who took you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage.” Classical Jewish commentators point out that instead of introducing Himself, “I am the creator of the entire universe,” a more impressive moniker to be sure, God chose to introduce Himself as the one who intervenes in human history—for our benefit.
This is an old theological debate: Having created the world, does God leave it to run on its own?
The God of Judaism intervenes in history, both in the macrocosm and the microcosm.
Judaism is a radical rejection of that idea. The God of Judaism intervenes in history, both in the macrocosm and the microcosm. God communicates with human beings, directly through prophecy during the Biblical era, and indirectly through what happens in our lives since then. Your getting caught in a traffic jam and missing your flight is a Divine communiqué; it’s up to you to decipher the message.
It’s easier to see what are customarily called “Acts of God”—such as hurricanes and earthquakes—as, well, acts of God. Either you believe in randomness—that things “just happen”—or you believe in some precise causal force. You could identify that force as “Nature.” (As a child, did you ever wonder who exactly “Mother Nature” is?) Or you could identify it as God.
If you believe in God as presented by Jewish sources, you recognize Divine control over not only whether a volcano will erupt, but whether your Wi-fi will go down; over not only whether it will rain today but whether you will give birth to a healthy baby. Judaism calls this Divine supervision, hashgacha in Hebrew. There is both general providence that directs whole populations, and individual providence that directs the minutia of the lives of individuals.
God created the world in order to have a relationship with human beings. Therefore, God is both involved in our lives and intervenes for our spiritual benefit, guiding the events of our lives in a way that will lead to our ultimate spiritual rectification. Illness, financial loss, or unemployment, albeit painful, may be the catalyst for rectification, which is the true purpose of human life. The bedrock of Judaism is that God is both involved and beneficent.
Thus, on Rosh Hashanah, God assesses the spiritual state of every human being and decrees what each person needs for their rectification. We tend to learn more from our difficult circumstances and tests than from days sunbathing on the beach. So Divine decrees are apt to include all manner of rigorous challenges, because this life is the “basic training” meant to turn us into the best human beings we can be.
But what if you are the victim of a human agent—the spouse who derides you, the co-worker who sabotages you, the neighbor who yells at you, the date who lies to you? Judaism insists that human beings have free will and are accountable for their actions. The irascible spouse, the plotting co-worker, the volatile neighbor, and the dishonest date are all responsible for their choices and will be held liable in a spiritual accounting system that is meticulous in its precision.
But where is God in these situations?
Volumes have been written by Jewish sages over the last 1500 years on the question of how Divine control interacts with human free choice. Is everything that happens to you the result of Divine decree, or can someone harm you (or help you) despite the decree you received on Rosh Hashana?
One position is that only God’s decree determines what happens to you, although other human beings have free choice whether they will be the agent of that decree. For example, if God determined on Rosh Hashanah that Jamie’s inflated ego needs to be rectified by being humiliated, that act of humiliation may come through a scolding by Jamie’s boss in front of the whole office staff.
But if Jamie’s boss decides not to do that (good choice!), the humiliation may come through an in-law, a neighbor, or a spouse. As the sages say, “God has many bears and lions.” The person who humiliated Jamie (a serious moral lapse according to the Torah) is accountable for his/her action. But Jamie’s suffering was determined by God. And if Jamie uses the experience for self-rectification rather than anger or taking revenge (also a transgression of the Torah), then the trial will have served the Divine purpose.
All agree that human beings have free will and nothing happens without God’s permission.
Other sources maintain that human choice can affect another person regardless of Divine decree. A criminal on a dark street late at night can choose to rob a passerby even if the passerby had no decree for financial loss. Then it is a matter of, in the face of a miscreant’s choice, whether God will intervene to protect the victim. This is a complicated theological question, involving how much merit the victim has, the degree of danger to which the victim exposed him/herself, and other factors. Sometimes, although God did not decree it, God permits it.
But all agree that, whether the source of the suffering is Divine decree or human choice, human beings have free will and nothing happens without God’s permission.
God’s control is often hardest to see in the testing ground called marriage. Most marriages degenerate sometimes or often into rounds of blaming and complaining. Yet, all the frustrations, disappointments, and irritations in our marriages come from Divine decree or at least Divine permission, in order to challenge us to react in a way that will cause us to become our best selves. That does not remove the onus of responsibility from the errant spouse. (Nor is it an invitation for abuse. The misbehaving spouse is always accountable for his/her bad choices.)
But as important as what your spouse did, which you cannot control, is your own reaction. If you react with blame or criticism in a futile effort to rectify your spouse (spouses do not change even by years of blame or criticism), you will have relinquished the opportunity to affect the only person you can change: yourself. Focusing on your own choices does not excuse your spouse’s wrong behavior. But it does empower you to act in the only sphere that is in your control: exercising your free will to fulfill your life’s purpose of spiritual growth and character development.
If you understand that marital challenges, like everything in your life, are a message from God offering a path for self-reflection (not guilt!) and self-improvement, then you will have scored a win/win/win victory. You will have strengthened your relationship with your spouse, with God, and with your own higher self.
And, yes, I always pray for a parking space. And I thank God when I get one.
Sara Yoheved Rigler gives a weekly marriage webinar for women, the Kesher Wife Workshop, based on spiritual principles and tools that have helped hundreds of wives.
Featured Image: Unsplash.com, Alevision.co

Great article.
When I lost my business and harbored not just a grudge, but extreme anger towards my business partner for his actions, I couldn't pick myself up and no matter how hard I tried, it remained a financial desert - for a long time. Then I remembered an article on Aish about the destructive force of anger and G-D departs when anger starts"
On the positive side, I am much closer to my spouse, because of this.
All is from the hand of G-D.
Thank you for writing the article.
WONDERFUL!
It disappoints me when I see "Judaism" framed this way. There are many, many Jews who see it differently. Are we not Jewish?
"Volumes have been written by Jewish sages over the last 1500 years on the question ..." If your presumptions were coherent, then it wouldn't require volumes to explain their inconsistencies.
"Other sources maintain that ..." True, there is no agreement on your version of Jewish theology.
"God created the world in order to have a relationship with human beings." You can't be serious! And, of course, you mean ALL human beings including Muslims who also claim to have a "special" relationship with God.
It is time to build a better, more inclusive, Judaism that doesn't depend on "the God of Judaism intervenes in history".
Since Judaism is from G-d, we can't just build a different one that satisfies our personal opinions or desires. Jews that see it differently are certainly still Jewish, they just don't understand Judaism.
Islam is also "from God". We have to rely on our intelligence to decide what is truly "from God" and what is not. We can freely discuss what makes Judaism what it is and we can critically examine what we believe about the development of the religion.
Like it or not, we all rely on personal opinions in the formation of our understanding of Judaism or any other religion.
Islam is not from G-d, Islam is from one man who claimed that he spoke to G-d which was a flagrant lie, and when it happened nobody believed him. Judaism, however, claims that G-d spoke to 3 million people and everyone at the time and a thousand years after continued to believe that. Only in later generations have we experienced the ability or more accurately the "desire" to deny a history that nobody for more than a thousand years denied or discounted. Can you account for such a thing? So please let's not equate Islam and Judaism.
We have different opinions and that leads to different beliefs. That's what your comment tells me.
As for the truth of your comments: Nobody believed Muhammad? God spoke to 3 million people? Where are you getting your information?
You need to take Islam more seriously. There are around 2 billion people today who believe that the Qur'an is the word of God.
I don't equate Islam and Judaism. Islam is the fruit of a single, illiterate man. Judaism is the fruit of generations of learned men. I don't need a Mount Sinai legend to justify Judaism, in fact, I believe that such a legend weakens Judaism by erasing its historical development and making it no different from Islam.
Many, and perhaps even most, Jews are not connected to Jewish learning, so their perspectives say little about Jewish thought. There is a plethora of Jewish thinking and much of it would not profess that G-d is involved with our finding a parking space - but not because He can't. There are only three basics: Hashem is omnipotent, omniscient, and all good. The good is the hardest to us to perceive because Hashem allows a lot of evil to play out, even when He could prevent it. The more one believes in Diving providence, the more he will witness its expression.
That Hashem decrees on Rosh Hashana who will live and who will die this year resonates with me. Through that lens, I'll stop worrying about the parking space and use the power of prayer for loftier goals. 🙂
Thank you for your thoughtful comment, Sharon.
I have trouble with a belief that God favours part of his creation over other parts and, therefore, for example, the idea that praying for the downfall of our enemies is something that an omniscient God would listen to.
The question that I ask is: Can you believe in the power of prayer without believing that there is a God who listens to your prayers?
Full of insight, as always! Brilliant.
B'H"... is our way of saying ... thank you