An Open Letter to Billy Crystal
The Ramban describes how every detail of our forefather’s lives was a signpost, indicating future events in the lives of their descendants. Yaakov’s wanderings in exile, as he fled first from the wrath of Eisav, and later from the jealousy of Lavan, foretold the exiles that his children would suffer throughout the ages. Yet throughout the difficult epochs of exile that we have endured, Hashem has stretched His protective wings over us, rescuing us from our enemies time and time again, just as He rescued Yaakov Avinu, in fulfillment of His vow, “I am with you; I will guard you wherever you go.”1
Rav Yaakov Emden writes:
When we contemplate our situation in the history of the world, we realize that we are a nation exiled, like scattered sheep. After all the thousands of years of hardship that have befallen us, there is no nation as oppressed as ours. Our enemies are numerous. With hatred and jealousy, they have raised their heads to uproot and destroy us. Even so, they have been unable to fulfill their plans. The most powerful of nations have risen against us and long ago fallen, their memory forgotten like a passing shadow, but we who cling to Hashem survive today. Despite all the torments of our exile, we have not forsaken even one letter of the written Torah, and the words of our Sages still stand strong. They have been impervious to the hand of time. What could the clever philosophers possibly say to explain this? That it is a coincidence?
By my life, I swear that this is a greater miracle than those Hashem performed for our forefathers in Egypt, in the desert, and in Eretz Yisrael. The longer the Exile lasts, the more the miracle becomes obvious and God's might is revealed. Everything that we undergo today was already foreseen by the prophets, who bemoaned the terrible length of the Exile long before it began. From all their words, not one has fallen aside. He who would dispute this, his words are like smoke and the passing clouds.2
The fortitude necessary to endure our exile was bequeathed to us by our forefathers, who suffered similar hardships throughout their lives. Avraham Avinu, the founder of our nation, also tasted the hardship of exile, when he fulfilled God's command, “Go for yourself from your land.” He was the first to assume the role of the wandering Jew, traveling from one land to another, not even knowing his destination, but trusting that God would ultimately bring him “to the land that I will show you.”
However, Avraham’s exile was very different from Yaakov’s. Avraham experienced the hardship of wandering in foreign lands, but Yaakov experienced a much more difficult exile, as he fled the unsheathed sword of a deadly adversary. To give him the encouragement he so desperately needed, Yaakov was granted a prophetic vision, in which God assured him of his survival in exile: an assurance that would stand for his descendants throughout the generations.
And he dreamt, and behold! A ladder was set earthward and its top reached heavenward; and behold! angels of God were ascending and descending on it. And behold! Hashem was standing over him, and He said, “I am Hashem, God of Avraham your father and God of Yitzchak; the ground upon which you are lying, to you will I give it and to your descendants. Your offspring shall be as the dust of the earth, and you shall spread out powerfully westward, eastward, northward, and southward; and all the families of the earth shall bless themselves by you and by your offspring. Behold, I am with you; I will guard you wherever you go, and I will return you to this soil; for I will not forsake you until I will have done what I have spoken about you.”3
The Ramban interprets this vision as follows: God revealed to Yaakov through a prophetic dream, that everything that occurs here on earth is orchestrated through the angels by Divine decree. The angels that God sends to walk the earth can perform no act, from the trivial to the momentous, until they have first returned to stand before the Lord of the world, to deliver their report, and state whether the land rests peacefully or is plagued by sword and bloodshed. God then directs the angels to return to earth to fulfill His bidding.
God's appearance over the ladder represented His firm assurance that Yaakov’s fate would not be entrusted to the hands of the angels. Yaakov was God's own portion, and God would always protect him personally, as it is written, “I shall be with you; I will guard you wherever you go.” In this respect, Yaakov was greater than other tzaddikim, of whom it is written, “He will charge His angels for you, to protect you in all your ways.”4
According to Rabbi Eliezer the Great, this vision paralleled Avraham’s Bris bein HaBesarim (Covenant of the Parts). God showed Yaakov how the four empires would ascend to power, and ultimately crumble. The angels on the ladder were the guardian angels of the empires: Greece, Babylon, Media, and Rome, as described by Daniel.5 God assured Yaakov that He would stand by Yaakov’s side to protect him as he wandered among the nations, and rescue him from their hands.
God showed him each empire’s ascent and its subsequent destruction. He showed him the guardian angel of Babylon ascending seventy rungs on the ladder, and then falling. He showed him the guardian angel of Media ascending 52 rungs and then falling. He showed him the guardian angel of Greece ascending one hundred and eighty rungs and then falling. He then showed him the angel of Edom ascending higher and higher, but it did not fall. Hashem then assured him, “But in the end, he shall fall into the abyss.”6 Hashem then said to Eisav, “If you raise [your nest] like an eagle, [or if you place your nest among the stars, I will bring you down
from there — the word of Hashem].”7
Yaakov’s adversaries were the spiritual forebears of the empires that were destined to oppress his descendants. Each enemy threatened Yaakov with a particular form of danger, which paralleled the dangers that the Children of Israel were destined to endure in exile. Eisav threatened him with physical destruction, representing nations such as Nazi Germany, which waged an open war to destroy the Children of Israel, irrespective of our level of religious observance.
The suffering Yaakov endured under Lavan’s hand was more insidious. Yaakov worked for him for 20 years, under conditions of hardship and depravation: “This is how I was: By day, scorching heat consumed me, and frost by night; my sleep drifted from my eyes.”8
Yet throughout it all he remained the very model of honest labor, as the Rambam writes: Just as an employer is forbidden to cheat his employees, or withhold their pay; so too an employee is forbidden to cheat his employer by shirking his duties here and there, until finally the entire day is wasted in deceit. He must be punctual and diligent in his work hours, for which reason our Sages exempted him from the fourth blessing of Birkas HaMazon. He must serve his employer with all his strength, as Yaakov the tzaddik said, “it was with all my might that I served your father.”9 Hashem rewarded him in this world for his honest labor, as it is written, “And the man was very, very successful.”10,11
Lavan prospered by Yaakov’s honest labor, but he never showed Yaakov the slightest bit of appreciation. Just the opposite, he constantly sought ways to cheat Yaakov, and deprive him of his basic rights. This foreshadowed the plight of the Children of Israel in lands such as Communist Russia, where their lives were spared, but their basic human rights were usurped. Jews played a role in the development of science, education, and trade in all the countries where we were exiled, yet we were often denied the opportunity to earn the most basic livelihood.
By enduring these difficult tests, and remaining faithful to Hashem throughout them all, Yaakov instilled in our nation the strength and fortitude necessary to survive the various stages of our exile. In his merit, Hashem stands beside us at all times, to rescue us from our adversaries, in whatever guise they may appear.
“In every generation they rise against us to destroy us, but HaKadosh Baruch Hu rescues us from their hands.”12
