The Pitt's Dr. Robby Needs a Jewish Intervention


5 min read
5 min read
7 min read
5 min read
Why relationships get harder before they get deeper.
A long-term relationship isn’t a straight line; it’s a series of messy, uncomfortable evolutions. Here are the common emotional stages that tend to show up in serious relationships, from long-term dating to marriage.
Understanding these stages matters because without a framework, you can misread growth as failure. What feels like distance can actually be development. What feels like loss can be the shedding of illusion.
Jewish tradition views love as something you build over time, and building things involves dust, friction, and a lot of heavy lifting.
This one is easy. You’re both on your best behavior, you’re finishing each other's sentences, and everything feels like a movie. But be honest: you don't actually know each other yet. You’re in love with a "trailer" for the person, not the whole film. It’s a beautiful stage, but it’s thin, incomplete. There’s generosity and optimism in this stage, but you haven’t yet seen how the other person shows up under pressure.
Differences eventually surface. Suddenly, you’re noticing the real stuff. It’s not just the big issues, but the friction of daily life—how you handle money, how long they pout after an argument, or the way they never quite shut the cabinet doors. Conversations that once felt simple now feel loaded.
This is often the moment couples begin to worry. Why does this feel harder than it used to?
This is where Judaism introduces a surprisingly honest idea about relationships. In the book of Genesis (2:18), when the first human relationship is created, the Torah describes the partner as an ezer k’negdo. It’s usually translated as “a helpmate,” but the literal meaning is far more nuanced: “a helper opposite him”—or even “a helper against him.”
At first glance, that sounds strange. How is opposition helpful? But Judaism’s insight is profound. A true partner isn’t meant to be your twin or your echo. They help you because they are different. They stand across from you, see what you can’t see, and challenge the parts of you that would otherwise remain undeveloped.
In this light, difference is not a design flaw—it’s the design itself. The tension that shows up in daily life isn’t a sign that something went wrong. It’s often the very mechanism through which growth happens. Your partner becomes your counterweight, balancing your blind spots and stretching you beyond your comfort zone.
That friction is not a mistake. It’s the point.
When those differences stop feeling interesting and start feeling personal, the ego steps in.
This is the stage when you begin to protect yourself. The disagreement itself starts to matter less than what it stirs up underneath. You start watching your words more carefully, or throwing them more sharply. You keep score.
Instead of asking, What’s happening between us? the question quietly becomes, How do I make sure I don’t lose here? The focus shifts from solving to protecting your position.
Being right — or creating a bit of distance — can start to feel safer than being open.
This stage is fueled by fear. Fear that if you soften, you’ll be overlooked. Fear that if you give in, you’ll disappear. Fear that your needs won’t matter unless you fight for them.
Many couples misinterpret this stage as a sign that love is fading. But that’s a mistake. It often shows up precisely because the relationship now matters enough to feel threatening. The attachment is real — and so is the risk.
Now comes the time to muster the courage to become vulnerable and forge a greater closeness through genuine respect and communication.
This is the part no one tells you about. At some point, a quieter realization sets in: your partner will not become the imagined version you hoped for. They won’t read your mind. They won’t respond exactly the way you would. They won’t fill every gap or soften every hard edge in your life.
And neither will you.
To reach a deeper place, you have to let the "imaginary" version of your partner die. The version of your partner who was supposed to make everything feel easier.
Letting go of that fantasy can feel like grief. There’s a sense of loss in realizing that love doesn’t rescue you from being human.
But there’s also relief. You stop negotiating with a version of the relationship that never actually existed. You stop waiting for someone to turn into who you hoped they’d be. You finally meet the person in front of you — and allow yourself to be seen as you are, too.
By this stage, something has settled. Love is being carried by a clearer understanding of who you’re with.
You now see your partner with more accuracy — their limits, their habits, the ways they struggle — and you see your own more clearly as well. The relationship becomes less about filling gaps and more about learning how to move through life together. Expectations are more realistic.
Chosen love grows out of a clear-eyed decision to care for the relationship, even when effort is required. You speak more thoughtfully because you understand the cost of careless words. You repair sooner because distance no longer feels dramatic or necessary. You stop keeping score because you’re invested in what you’re building over time.
Kindness here takes intention. Forgiveness becomes part of how the relationship functions, shaped through repetition and repair. Trust deepens through experience — through seeing what the relationship can hold.
This is the kind of love that can absorb real life: illness, fatigue, boredom, pressure, change. It doesn’t depend on constant emotional intensity to feel alive. It holds steady through ordinary days that ask for patience rather than passion.
From the outside, it may not look impressive. From the inside, it feels stable enough to build a life on.

This is a good guide if you have100 years to get from one stage to another. Sorry life is not so segmented. but I do appreciate your words and hope you don't take my criticisim as not being appropriate
This is a beautiful and insightful discussion of how good love develops through self-awareness and choice, and i say this after 28 years of marriage that has survived and, with work, thrived in the face of alcoholism and several other hardships. That said,
i suggest including a section on how to choose to walk away from “love,” because the stages of discomfort and pain sometimes reveal that the differences are profound and foundational and it’s ok,
good and wise and choose to say no.
A lovely honest explanation of the long term development of mature, lasting love. Thank you
So beautifully stated about the true and un discussed realities of long term love. Extremely well done! Thank you! So refreshing.
Outstanding and educational well worth the read, thank you! There's an old saying my father used to always speak on, anything worth having is worth fighting for and that's exactly what a good marriage is.
I enjoyed this article for the way the author packages the reality so concisely. I wish all people could see the error in relying upon the myth that the excitement generated by the initial attraction is love and they could see the value in sticking with the relationship through all five stages.
If the “marriage as it should be” is not based on material expectations but rather on dedication to learning and a Jewish home, how should a spouse manage when the other spouse decides that is not what was really wanted?
If your partner is supposedly your bashert then why must one go through all those stages to achieve "lasting love"? Going through all those stages may take many, many years so in the meantime what? What if love never comes? Familiarity can breed contempt. If one must go through this right from the start of the marriage then you're only settling. I'd rather be single than settle.
If you remove emotionalism, and "romance" from a relationship, and insert maturity, and unity of purpose, and mutual care and admiration, and a sense of obligation to the best welfare for a partner; you will have the same amount of success, maybe more, and less pain, and associated "disaster area" fallout when, and if it fails.
Make sure both parties have a prenup agreement and NDA, so there can be maturity and peace, in the event it ends.
What you are looking for here is to protect the children, if there are any, under all circumstances, and regardless.
Be realistic. Be truthful with yourselves.
The Ketuba is a “pre-nup”, although it’s fine to have a civil one as well if there are additional issues to manage.
Thanks for writing.
Thanks for writing. Understood, however, religious documents typically have zero weight in civil law. The law typical is blind to religion.
Wow, that’s a lot. But great. Thank you!
How do the above natural cognitive process stages roll-out when your bashert best-friend survives complex traumatic brain injuries impacting the parietal region, and disassociative multiple personality disorders emerge thereafter accompanied by amnesia, and limbic brain dominant behavior inducing estragement from loved ones?
Sending hugs and support - that sounds so incredibly painful and difficult! Take care of yourself!
You have to be the mature adult for the both of you.
Depends upon what your moral positioning is. If marriage, to you, is only about easy roads, it would appear your spouse is out of luck.
I don’t have an answer to your question. But I hope you seek help from a professional to navigate this. What you’re describing is beyond the “norm”. ❤️