Stephen Colbert and Kate Middleton’s Diagnosis

Advertisements
Advertisements
March 27, 2024

3 min read

FacebookTwitterLinkedInPrintFriendlyShare

How avoiding the pitfalls of assumptions promotes empathy and understanding in our interactions.

In the world of comedy and punditry, it can be easy to make assumptions and jokes about public figures without considering the consequences. Stephen Colbert recently made some jokes about the disappearance of Kate Middleton, the Duchess of Cambridge. He was embarrassed and regretful when it was revealed that Kate Middleton had been diagnosed with cancer.

Middleton's diagnosis reminds us of the dangers of making assumptions. When you jump to conclusions and mock others without having all the facts, you risk causing harm and perpetuating hurtful stereotypes. This situation highlights the need to be mindful of the impact of your words and actions, especially regarding delicate matters such as health or personal struggles.

A contrite Colbert retracted his jokes once he learned the truth about Middleton's condition. Even those who make a living out of mocking others can recognize when they have crossed a line and take responsibility for their actions. It serves as a lesson about the importance of empathy, compassion, and humility in your interactions with others.

As Oscar Wilde famously said, “When you assume, you make an ass out of u and me.” Take the time to gather information and consider different perspectives before forming opinions or making jokes at someone else's expense.

The antidote to making false assumptions starts with a willingness to admit that you don't know. Unless someone shares their inner world with you, you can't know what's really going on.

Become more attuned to the distinction between facts and opinions.

For example, the "sky is blue" is a fact, while the perception of it being “pretty” is an opinion. With the awareness between "fact" and "opinion," you can challenge and question your assumptions before they lead to harmful actions or words, helping you avoid rushing to judgment and prevent misunderstandings and hurtful behavior toward others.

The Jewish concept of "judging favorably," known as "dan l'kaf zechut," judging to the side of merit, provides further insight into navigating the complexities of making assumptions. This principle encourages individuals to give others the benefit of the doubt and interpret their actions in the best possible light, even when faced with ambiguous or questionable behavior.

The concept of judging favorably is rooted in the understanding that humans are inherently fallible and that there may be circumstances or motivations underlying someone's actions that are not immediately apparent. By judging favorably, you are encouraged to avoid rushing to negative conclusions and approach situations with compassion, empathy, and understanding.

Consider alternative explanations for someone's behavior before jumping to negative conclusions. Rather than immediately attributing malicious intent to an individual's actions, judging favorably invites you to explore the possibility of extenuating circumstances or a different perspective that can offer a more benevolent interpretation.

By incorporating the concept of judging favorably into your interactions and decision-making processes, you can cultivate a mindset of generosity, empathy, and fairness. This approach mitigates the potential for misunderstandings, conflicts, and harm that may arise from hasty assumptions and creates a more compassionate and understanding society.

Kudos to Colbert for publicly taking back his words. And my heartfelt prayers to Kate Middleton and her family – may she and her father-in-law King Charles have a complete and speedy healing.

Click here to comment on this article
guest
69 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Hovorka
Hovorka
15 days ago

Well said. Sadly, there are those who don't care, no matter what. Like, "Fake News" MORONS!

. James Joseph Lueckenhoff
. James Joseph Lueckenhoff
16 days ago

this, to me, is the logical conclusion to our warped sense of humor now a days. humor, supposedly humor, now seems to be centered around character assassination, making fun, playing the know it all. this is sad when compared to humor of not too long ago where comedians were more into laughing at their own foibles or the seemingly inconsistencies of life. to me the Dean Martin Celebrity Roasts where white, black, Jew, Christians, male, female and on and on had fun and a sense of faith. Humor, humanity and humility have the word 'humus' as the root.............humus being decayed vegetation. Might we realize that pointing at another's faults or assuming we know everything defies humor because it defies humility. rather be humble than humiliated. Faith and a sense of humor.

Last edited 16 days ago by . James Joseph Lueckenhoff
Max H
Max H
16 days ago

It's interesting that many try to defend him be saying 'but he's a comedian' as if that appellation somehow gives one 'licence to kill' (i.e. cruelly mock). In Judaism mockery is considered a spiritually horrific act, described by some kabbalists as the ultimate level of tumah (spiritual negativity). It's especially insidious since somehow our society has been duped into thinking its okay. As evidence it's a weapon, think back to your most painful childhood memories and they are likely to have some form of mockery at their center. Cynical 'comedy' is far from the innocent pastime many claim it to be.

Doug Burrows
Doug Burrows
17 days ago

The British media were the worsy offenders.

Keith
Keith
17 days ago

However he did not apologise did he

Grace
Grace
17 days ago

Colbert made a mistake. He made that mistake publicly. He is man who has gone through a lot in his life. He understands the fragility of life. I saw his apology, and I thought it was humbling and sincere. For the most part his observations are witty and on the mark. He usually focuses on those who are cruel and and in the public eye. When I saw his jokes I thought they were not in character. He made a mistake. I find it interesting that an article about being dan l'kav zechus seems not to be applicable to Colbert according to the comments. I'm a fan. I'm also a fan of Kimmel.

Ruth
Ruth
16 days ago
Reply to  Grace

That tells me your mind set.
I object colbert and Kimmel. They make big money on every ones expense. No trick to make fun of people. They need to make fun of their fears and short commings. Then they have plenty of Material.

Grace
Grace
16 days ago
Reply to  Ruth

What's my mindset? One that has room for human error. One that recognizes the frailty of all of us. I admire Stephen for being willing to share his enormous life losses that few could come out of it with sanity. As someone who experienced loss at an early age not on as grand a scale as he did, I recognize his ability to turn pain into humor. I also admire Jimmy for the work he has done for children with heart ailments and his ability when his family went through this was able to recognize his privilege and how other people go through these challenges with much less wealth. BTW they both use self-deprecating humor plenty of times and it is turning our shared fears into humor which allows us to take a step back and examine the fear. I wish you well and joy. Have a good Shabbos or a nice week

Kate the great
Kate the great
17 days ago

Colbert sucks I never watch him and this is one reason why.He speaks before he thinks.

Fan
Fan
17 days ago

My wish fort the royal family is that the world just cuts them some slack. It’s just one thing after another. It’s not nice.

Edward
Edward
17 days ago

Anyone who has actually read Wilde will know on sight of this silly cliche that he said no such thing.

Meanwhile, Colbert is a comedian and the British Royal Family are fair game. The palace could easily have dispelled the rumours anytime they wanted with a clear public statement (which would have necessitated no specific level of detail or any involvement from Kate Windsor). They did not do so, because it was more important to them to play whatever game they were up to.

When the nation pays millions for your upkeep, people are going to feel they have an interest in your public participation, regardless of how vapid you may be or how anachronistic the institution of which you are a part.

Lizzie
Lizzie
17 days ago

He did not take back his words accusing Prince William of having an affair which was the more damaging “joke”. Don’t go patting him on the back. It was a non-apology apology.

Lara
Lara
17 days ago

Someone wise once said that everyone is judging by the level of his own spoilage. Was interesting to learn about Jewish concept of "dan l'kaf zechut”. I personally try to use a second one.

B. Koonce
B. Koonce
17 days ago

It isńt necessary to be mean to be funny. Being mean shows your true character and need to put others down to feel better.

Becky
Becky
17 days ago

He's disgusting as is Kimmel.

Lori
Lori
17 days ago
Reply to  Becky

Guess YOU dont have empathy. How can you make a remark like that? It takes a REAL person WITH empathy to admit when their wrong.

Rosalie Porcelli
Rosalie Porcelli
17 days ago

Stephen Colbert is always making fun of people and assuming the worst about people.. Just goes to show you how despicable his comments are. He is not funny and I don't even know why he thinks he is. I saw his show onetime and have never watched it since. His apology holds no merit with me. Too little too late.

Lori
Lori
17 days ago

Your opinion means nothing. You watched his show ONCE. He's a comedian ( duh?) for many years. Not all can be funny everyday. He is VERY funny. You just may NOT UNDERSTAND his jokes. Most likely!

Sharon Sanders
Sharon Sanders
17 days ago

He is an entertainer... Although his comments werent nice regarding the princess. Everyone is fair game in his book. He is in the business to entertain and get laughs.. when he ceases to do this.. he will be replaced.

Sharon Sanders
Sharon Sanders
17 days ago
Reply to  Sharon Sanders

His job; to entertain.. to take things that arouse curiosity among people...and put a twist on them.. making his audience laugh..
People need to be discerning when they watch him.

Rexy
Rexy
17 days ago
Reply to  Sharon Sanders

I agree that Mr. Colbert is abusive & cruel. I don't find that funny or amusing! Thank you for the invitation to express my opinion. I wish you well.

Jim
Jim
17 days ago
Reply to  Sharon Sanders

He, Like the rest of mainstream comedians.
Is a liberally motivated entertainer. Only what he considers to be the opposition( Conservatives) Is considered Fair game.
He has a plethora of easy jokes to be made about Biden.Or harris , but that never Happens. He will only be canceled when he Mistakenly anger's the wrong powerful liberal And Becomes another casualty Of the liberal elitist hypocritical cult Known as Hollywood.

Ayuvines
Ayuvines
17 days ago

Colbert’s statement was not an “apology”. It was a “please don’t contact my sponsors” CYA statement. And to repeat what many are pointing out, she is HRH PRINCESS CATHERINE,. While the world knows she is “Kate”, it is surprisingly disrespectful to see a journalist be so bold as not use her proper title.

Beverly
Beverly
17 days ago

He's mean and NOT funny. Same with Jimmy! Two sad men. Sorry to hear that these two men make a living destroying Kate and Donald Trump's family. Get a life

Lori
Lori
17 days ago
Reply to  Beverly

Aaahh that explains your comment. You cant handle the jokes( their jokes), mostly the plain truth about trump, you cant even write a joke when it comes to trump. He is the JOKE. Lol !! you MUST be republican.

Carly
Carly
17 days ago

Who is Kate Middleton? Does this writer not know any better? Refer to Catherine, Princess of Wales properly- in an article about respect, no less!

Edward
Edward
17 days ago
Reply to  Carly

Maybe the writer does not support this silly, outdated institution. In any case, the purpose of a proper name is to uniquely identify the bearer, which "Kate Middleton" does perfectly well.

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago

I have no symptfor Steve Colbert or Jimmy Kimmel. They are both in the category of conceited individuals who have no regard for people who are more likely to be better than themselves. I will never watch either so-called entertainers who constantly criticize stars, politicians etc.

Shelly
Shelly
17 days ago

I agree with you 100%. They are self centered and mock anyone and anything that does not fit in with their agenda.

Lori
Lori
17 days ago
Reply to  Shelly

????

Lori
Lori
17 days ago

They are Comedians!! What dont you get?
Dont take it so personnaly. Cant take a JOKE, so sad your life must be. Politicians are the brunt of most jokes. From ANY comedians????

Lori
Lori
17 days ago

BTW, Colbert has raised LOTS of money for people who find themselves in natural disasters. One comes to mind. Hurricane Maria, hit San Juan in September 2017. He raised money for that disaster. When our idiot President only flew down there to throw paper towels at these people of need. (WHAT AN INSULT!!) THERE WAS NO EMPATHY THERE!! Thanks for embarassing the USA, DT ( i cant even say his name.)

Jeanne Baldwin
Jeanne Baldwin
17 days ago
Reply to  Lori

Lori, don't forget that Stephen has a show a couple times a year, where he gives homeless dogs the spotlight on tv !!!. He cares about dogs, especially the poor, sad, old, sick dogs left on the streets by uncaring humans. I believe he reaches out to Dog Rescue Groups and or Shelters to bring in dogs currently ready to be adopted. I think that of all those shows I have watched, all the dogs have been adopted. Thanks, Stephen ❤️💁‍♂️🐕

Lori
Lori
17 days ago
Reply to  Jeanne Baldwin

Thank you for saying that.
My reply was soley for people in general. BUT. You are right! I love him for that, I love animals, happy to agree with you.
Animals werent mentioned in the comment. Thats why I dudnt mention it. But, THANK YOU FOR THAT REMINDER. GOD BLESS!!

Jeanne Baldwin
Jeanne Baldwin
17 days ago

That is exactly what you are doing in your own statement.

Ro Marks
Ro Marks
17 days ago

Catherine is the Princess of Wales not just the Duchess of Cambridge. Colbert was absolutely appalling, feeding the gossip mill with a rumour that not only could seriously hurt two families but has been roundly debunked. May the Princess have refuah shlemah.

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago
Reply to  Ro Marks

Agree

Edward
Edward
17 days ago
Reply to  Ro Marks

The rumour has been *denied*, not debunked.

John Province
John Province
18 days ago

Stephen Colbert is not one man. He is a valuable enterprise worth hundreds of millions. His side saddle apology was about protecting a brand and and assuaging Sponsors. If the Conga line of retractions and repeat incidents we see on The View is any indicator Colbert will get a pass and continue on just as he always has.

Kettly laumonier
Kettly laumonier
18 days ago

I am soooo angry at news ,gossips, supposition make up stories and the total lack of compassion and empathy for anyone no matter what your titles is.They were so hounded with crazy suppositions that CHARLES AND CATHERINE WERE FORCE to divulge and share their diseases with the world when I am certain that from personal knowledge it probably felt like an abomb hit them. I lost 4 close family members in 2yrs and still can't find peace .This dreadful disease destroyed everything in its path and the uncertainty is in itself a true horror story. I don't like this world we are living in that's why I don't listen to the news, and I'm totally in awe how grateful she spoke when she "had"to defend herself "I will continue to pray for alllll who knows about this terror call "cancer"

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago

Totally agree

Madelon Wilson
Madelon Wilson
18 days ago

Apology? I saw his retraction, but never heard him actually say he was sorry or use the word "apology/apologize"... Probably just wanted to protect his ratings.

Denise Enriquez
Denise Enriquez
18 days ago
Reply to  Madelon Wilson

YES!! JUST LIKE KIM KARTRASHIAN SPEWED UGLY WORDS AND SAID SHE WOULD NEVER APOLOGIZE!! DISGUSTING EVIL (ELITE$)!!!!

John Province
John Province
18 days ago
Reply to  Madelon Wilson

Highly likely it was to calm nervous Sponsors threatening to leave.

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago
Reply to  John Province

Agree with you.

Irena Herr
Irena Herr
18 days ago

First of all Catherine Princess of Wales is not Kate Middleton calling her by her maiden name is as insulting as making fun of her situation

Bobbie
Bobbie
18 days ago

We all should keep are comments to our self, until we know the facts. Why does she even have to explain.

Paula Woerner
Paula Woerner
18 days ago

You should be ashamed of yourself for reporting about Princess Catherine…. Please please think before you speak next time… Thank You

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago
Reply to  Paula Woerner

He may think before he speaks but I will never watch him.

Deborah
Deborah
18 days ago

Why speculate at all? I wish her and King Charles, and anyone else with cancer the best, and a speedy, complete recovery. However, their health is none of our business, regardless of the fact that they are public figures. Does it not occur to these people who made fun or came up with ridiculous conspiracies, that it might have been more serious? Now they feel contrite! I didn’t think my opinion of Stephen Colbert or the “ladies” on The View could sink any lower but they never disappoint, do they?

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago
Reply to  Deborah

So true!

Wendell Hall
Wendell Hall
18 days ago

It is a wonderful article. I do wish everyone would call her by her real name, Catherine Mountbatten-Windsor or The Princess of Wales. Her name is not Kate (and she has made it clear she does not like the name) nor is her last name Middleton. I think it’s respectful.

Edward
Edward
17 days ago
Reply to  Wendell Hall

Agreed. No more dead-naming!

LesAscowitz
LesAscowitz
18 days ago

Stepping up to correcting your actions is the first step to making respected views…

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago
Reply to  LesAscowitz

These people didn’t have a choice. They should be totally embarrassed and ashamed of their actions and someone should be held responsible.

Rachel
Rachel
17 days ago

I don’t know what you mean by “someone should be held responsible.” The First Amendment guarantees freedom of speech. If you watched Colbert’s statement, it was clear that he felt badly for his inappropriate jokes. In this environment, public figures are going to be the butt of jokes. The Palace should have better PR advisors and should hire a professional photographer. I do agree that when someone releases a statement about surgery or other medical issues, they should be taken at their word. There are many US politicians I dislike, but I daven for their recovery if they are in poor health.

Ed Fleischman
Ed Fleischman
18 days ago

Why did she release “fake” picture?

Rachel
Rachel
18 days ago
Reply to  Ed Fleischman

She enjoys photography as a hobby. Nonetheless, she should probably hire a pro who will work with her before releasing pics.
I wish her, the King and everyone else facing medical difficulties a speedy and complete recovery.

Scott
Scott
18 days ago

Sorry, Stevie. The words are out there in the wild. No amount of "walking back", "contrition" or other forms of self-flagellation will undo it.

Wendell Hall
Wendell Hall
18 days ago
Reply to  Scott

Agree. Colbert is bully and a jerk, and no apology means anything coming from his mouth. He makes a living mocking people, being cruel and unkind. Don’t be taken in with his “apology.” He is only sorry it all backfired on him — that’s it.

Ann Biggs
Ann Biggs
18 days ago
Reply to  Wendell Hall

Yes, he slanders Prince William and mocks Princess Catherine and no SORRY in his follow up. What a jerk, I guess it's the Irish Catholic in him that makes him hate our Royal Family. I am switching to Jimmy Kimmel, funnier and a nicer person

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago
Reply to  Ann Biggs

I agree with you but switching to Jimmy Kimmel is just as bad or worse.

Rexy
Rexy
17 days ago

Try Jimmy Fallon. His history with Saturday Night Live makes him an established stand-up comedian. An added plus is his band The Roots, of Philadelphia PA. ❤️

Rachel
Rachel
17 days ago
Reply to  Ann Biggs

Some have also been spreading gossip about a titled Lady who is a longterm friend of HRH William and the Royal Family. She deserves an apology from those who have slandered her.

Denise Enriquez
Denise Enriquez
18 days ago
Reply to  Wendell Hall

AGREED 💯% STUPIDITY AT ITS FINEST STEVEN COLON'BERT!! 🤨

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago
Reply to  Wendell Hall

Agree totally. Including Jimmy Kimmel and The View so called ladies!

Kettly laumonier
Kettly laumonier
18 days ago
Reply to  Scott

My medical records is no one business.

Denise Enriquez
Denise Enriquez
18 days ago
Reply to  Scott

SCOTT 💯% CORRECT ON THAT STATEMENT!!
DAMAGE ALREADY DONE!! NO AMOUNT OF (taking it back/ I'm sorry) IS GONNA FIX WHAT HAD ALREADY "SPEWED" OUT OF HIS PEDO' MOUTH!!😠

Pauline Haufler
Pauline Haufler
17 days ago
Reply to  Scott

True.

EXPLORE
LEARN
MORE
Explore
Learn
Resources
Next Steps
About
Donate
Menu
Languages
Menu
Social
.