An Open Letter to Billy Crystal


I opened the floor to your questions. One of them broke my heart.
My team had been asking me to do an “Ask Jamie” episode for a long time, and I finally worked up the courage. We collected your questions from social media, and my assistant and production manager, Arianne, read them to me one by one. I didn’t know what was coming which was half the fun.
Some answers were easy. What do I miss about America after 14 and a half years in Israel? Toasted sesame oil, plum vinegar, parking (that one’s really for my husband) and, most of all, family. Others were confessions. I wrote Brisket 101 and I don’t eat meat. I’ve never had a single bite of steak.
Then Arianne read this one: “Is there more to being Jewish than antisemitism?”
To me, that was the saddest question of the whole episode. It’s an honest question, and I know the feeling behind it is out there. That’s what makes it so tragic.
Antisemitism is exploding and it’s right that we speak out against it. Holocaust and October 7th education matter. But if a Jew grows up believing that being targeted is the beginning and end of what it means to be Jewish, then we haven’t done our job as a people, or as Jewish educators, in teaching the next generation.
Being Jewish is one of the most beautiful gifts we have in life. Being part of the chosen people means we were given a responsibility, a mission: to bring light, beauty and God’s presence into this world. According to the Torah, the Jewish people are meant to be “a light unto the nations.” It’s hard to be a light if all you know about yourself is that other people want to put you out.
Imagine inheriting your great-grandmother’s recipe box, packed with handwritten cards for the dishes that fed your family for generations. Now imagine that the only thing anyone ever told you about it was that people once tried to steal it. You’d guard that box with your life, but you’d never open it. You’d never taste a single thing inside. A Jewish identity built only on antisemitism is a bit like that. We protect it fiercely, but we never get to enjoy what’s inside.
Another person wrote that I’d inspired them to grow closer to Judaism, and they wanted to know what keeps me connected. Messages like that give me tremendous strength.
But my biggest inspiration is Hubby and the kids. Hubby is always learning and always sharing what he learns with us, especially about faith in God, trust in God and believing that everything is for the good. In Hebrew those ideas are called emunah (faith) and bitachon (trust), and in our home they aren’t abstract concepts. They’re the conversations at our table.
That’s what being Jewish looks like for me, and none of it has anything to do with antisemitism. I don’t see myself as an activist, but if there’s one thing I want to advocate for, it’s a relationship with God. That relationship doesn’t come from being hated. It comes from learning.
Hatred can remind you that you’re Jewish, but it can never tell you why. It can’t explain why we light candles on Friday night, why we say a blessing before we eat, or why our people have held on to the same words and the same hopes for more than 3,000 years. For that, you have to open the books. The Torah is our guidebook to living the most fulfilled life possible. Every time you learn something new, you uncover more of the richness, depth and beauty that has been yours all along.
I know this from my own life. I wasn’t raised observant. I chose this life, and I hope the way I live it says more than any speech could: where I live, how I dress and how I raise my family. But none of it happened by accident, and none of it happened overnight.
A relationship with God isn’t something you’re simply handed. You have to want it. You have to go looking for it, actively explore it, and then keep fighting for it, even on the days it feels far away. That’s true in Jerusalem, and it’s true wherever you live. The people who hate us will always try to define us by what they want to take away. Learning is how we discover everything we have.
If you’ve only ever experienced being Jewish as something under threat, here are a few questions worth asking yourself:
Then take one small step. Find your local Aish branch and try a weekly class. Sign up for Aish Partners in Torah, which matches you with a study partner to learn one-on-one, online or by phone, on any subject you choose. There’s no excuse. You can do it in your pajamas, camera on or off. If you’re in Jerusalem, stop by the Dan and Hytman Family Aish World Center at One Western Wall Plaza for free drop-in Aish Essentials classes, Sunday through Thursday.
Someone also asked where I see myself in ten years. I hope I’ll have grown in my learning, my character and my trust in God. I don’t expect to be a finished product, and none of us are. But my hope for the next ten years isn’t only for me. I hope the person who asked whether there’s more to being Jewish than antisemitism, and everyone who has quietly wondered the same thing, will spend those years discovering just how much more there is.
Watch the full Ask Jamie episode, and leave your questions in the comments. If you enjoy it, we’ll do another one.
