Charlie Kirk, Shabbat, and the Secret of Jewish Survival


5 min read
4 min read
4 min read
4 min read
Here’s what actually works—and it’s not what you think.
I’ve been noticing a theme lately in couple’s sessions.
She’s frustrated. He’s shutting down. She’s naming the problems—one after the other—and he’s sitting there, not sure if he’s supposed to defend himself or just nod along.
Then he finally says what he’s been holding in for the past 20 minutes: “Why am I the one who has to change?”
It’s a fair question.
No one enters a relationship to become a project. And yet, somewhere along the way, many women feel compelled to “help” their husbands become better versions of themselves.
He should be more spiritual.
He should help out more.
He should be more present with the kids.
He should, he should, he should…
Your instincts may not be wrong. On the contrary—women are relationship beings. We feel the tension in the air before there’s even been an argument. We sense distance before it shows up in words.
Women are emotionally wired to detect misalignment. And often, that intuition is spot on.
We’re the early warning system, the ones who know when something feels off—even when we can’t explain it.
But what do we do with that gift?
It’s one thing to sense that something is wrong. It’s another thing to communicate that in a way that doesn’t feel like attack, criticism, or judgment.
It’s one thing to want more from your husband. It’s another to try to fix him.
The Torah describes the first wife as an ezer k’negdo—a “helper opposite him” (Genesis, 2:18). It sounds contradictory. How can you help someone by opposing them?
It means we are meant to be our husbands’ mirrors—not their judges. It means we reflect back what we see in them—not through sarcasm, but through sincerity.
Not with frustration, but with faith. We help—not by nagging—but by believing.
If you’ve ever felt that your husband could be so much more, you’re probably right. But the question is: do you see his potential in a way that inspires him, or in a way that discourages him?
Take a look at how you’re speaking up.
There’s a huge difference between “Why are you always on your phone?” and “I miss you. Can we carve out some time together this evening?”
Your words should come from a place of connection, not criticism.
Between “You never help with the kids” and “It really means a lot to me when you put them to bed. They adore you.”
Tone, timing, and trust matter.
Your words should come from a place of connection, not criticism.
I once heard it said: “A man changes for a woman not when she’s disappointed in him, but when he feels she truly believes in who he can become.”
Your husband doesn’t need a therapist. He needs a partner.
He doesn’t need a lecture. He needs a light. Someone who brings out his best without making him feel like a failure in the process.
And sometimes, the hardest work is the inner work.
Sometimes what’s really needed is not for him to change—but for you to practice acceptance (and to be clear, I am not talking about an abusive situation).
Maybe what’s needed is to let go of the fantasy version of him and honor the real human being you married. Instead of fixing him, you’re growing together in a safe emotional space where the two of you can evolve.
So, want to fix your man? Don’t.
Instead, notice. Encourage. Inspire. Reflect his goodness back to him in a way that makes him want to rise.
And most importantly: Be the kind of woman whose presence makes it easy to grow.
Not because you pushed. But because you loved.

Also, let the little things go- don’t sweat the small stuff!
I assume this advice goes both ways…
Incidentally, it was through Aish (speed dating app) that I met my wonderful husband - we just celebrated our 21st anniversary!
stunning and well said!
I’m spiritual. My husband is not. Admittedly, neither of us was religious when we met in university and married a year later. I then became Orthodox a few years later. My husband is a genuinely good person, but he has no interest in being religious. He’s fine about keeping kosher, but is not a shulgoer.
Pushing does not work, but neither does quiet faith if the other person is not interested.
This article is simple and interesting.
I will add my two cents here
Your tongue is the sharpest tool you have, use it wisely and take great care with what comes out, when you speak to your husband or loved ones, ( yes easier said than done).
Personally for me, if I were to get married again, ( and one day I will🙏) I would do and be all that I would want from him. After all, it takes two to tango💃🏽💃🏽
MEN ARE NOT GOING TO LIKE MY COMMENT BUT: I DON'T BELIEVE THAT HUSBANDS HAVE THE SAME ABILITY, IN TERMS OF CHANGING AND MEETING THEIR WIVES' NEEDS. IN MY 55 YEARS OF MARRIAGE I HAVE MET FEW MEN WHO ARE CAPABLE OF CHANGING OR MEETING THEIR WIVES NEEDS, MY MOTHER (Z"L) USED TO TELL ME THAT IN A MARRIAGE IT WAS WOMEN AT 70 PERCENT AND MEN AT 30 PERCENT IN BUILDING A MARITAL RELATIONSHIP. SHE WAS MARRIED 70 YEARS. MEN ARE OFTEN STILL BOYS OR TOO STUBBORN AND/OR TOO BUSY SATISFYING THEIR OWN PERSONAL NEEDS TO REALLY SEE THE WHOLE PICTURE. THIS IS NOT TO PUT DOWN THE MALE POPULATION BUT IT IS WHAT IT IS! A WOMAN WHO DECIDES TO MAKE A "BAYIT" MUST REALIZE THAT IT IS MOSTLY UP TO HER TO CREATE "SHALOM BAYIT' AS I REALIZED HOW CORRECT MY MOTHER (Z"L) WAS AND ACCEPTED THIS REALITY I WAS HAPPIE
With the exception of intermittent crises (such as the death of a parent or a job losses), I think younger people are more likely to accept that both partners need to give 100% each. Don’t marry someone who is too immature. If a man is “too busy”, that may be because he is under intense pressure at work while helping to support your family. Try to see his perspective.
The is not whether men are going to "like" a message shouted (all in caps). Looking at men as "still boys" or "too busy satisfying their own personal needs" will GUARANTEE that there will be no change. Why should ANYONE change when the "other person" has such a negative view? It sounds more as if the writer simply "learned" from her mother, applied what she "learned", and now has a self-fulfilling prophecy. To put it differently, what are those "wifely needs" that a husband is unable to meet? They are not specified here. Are they "reasonable"? I agree that it is the woman (in most cases) who decides the Shalom Bayit -- for the reasons in the article above.
I read that a Rabbi once told a woman who complained about her husband that her analysis of her husband's flaws was "correct". However, he then pointed out that she had a choice: She could be "correct" and have a less than optimal marriage OR she could be accepting and note all the positive traits .... and have a much happier marriage.
Will you also write an article on fixing your wife? Who's to say who needs fixing?
Thank you so very much for a great article. To put the positive action into words, is truly amazing!! Thank you again for illuminating the lives of many. May Hashem bless you!! LD.
“Why am I the one who has to change?”
It’s a fair question.
Is it, though? Because you're in a relationship -- not a slave owner. Sheesh. It takes 2 to tango. So tired of these articles where women have to do all the emotional labor and it's still our fault if the man is unhappy. Why isn't he working on himself? Why isn't he doing all he can to be the best person he can be? Was he doing that before the marriage?
The answer is because while the husband is not a "slave owner", the wife is not a mashgiach. And, THAT is why it is legitimate for him to ask "why does HE have to change". When she married her husband, it should NOT have been with intent to change or improve him. Let her work on herself to see her husband's GOOD characteristics. And, if it is REALLY serious, let her speak to a Rav (or a frum / sensitive therapist) and get some guidance how to address the matter (if it is indeed, that serious).
How about this:
Just remember: God sees and hears you. You are both under obligation to do your very best, always.
This eliminates the need for picking on each other.
Your purpose it to be fruitful, and multiple; that is your focus.
Bickering and fault-finding in a marriage, is as having a plank in your eye while trying to gouge out a speck in your partner's eye. You are really more at fault, because these are not loving-kind ways. And that goes for men and women; husbands and wives.
And, think to the example you set for your children.
How do you know what G0d does or whether he or she hears us?
Isn't it possible folks, that not long after people are married, they realize for certain if they are not really in love, or don"t really like the person they married as much as they thought, after all?
And how often does that happen? I think more than realized.
Instead of being honest, they pick and hound and relentlessly require every fine detail of dissatisfaction to be changed, like picking away at a speck in the eye?
People are as they chose to be long before you ever met them, typically, both men and women.
People get married to have children, but if children grow up seeing this, and learn this, really what's the point if it only invites a repetitive cycle of unhappiness, and dissatisfaction?
This isn't real love.
I will tell you something important I heard/read some long time ago.
A person may not remember something you said or did to them long after the event, but they will remember how you made them feel.
The person you are married to is supposed to be the one you love most in the world. Why would you want to hurt them with harsh criticisms and impatient jibes and putdowns?
They will not maybe remember what you've said; but, they will remember if you made them feel unloved, and that is very hard to make go away once done.
What can I say? It's always the woman's fault if the marriage/marital relationship is headed for the dumpster.
That is not true and simply sounds like "sour grapes". The author pointed out ONE area where women APPEAR to be "guilty" more often. There is no mention here of any other instances where the marriage is "heading for the dumpster" -- which may very well be the fault of the husband.
The togue-in-cheek title of an Off-Broadway musical says it well: "I Love You. You're Perfect. Now Change". 😉
How much I knew this by reading so many books about men and striving to do the opposite of jokes men keep making about women. My husband is so happy with me but outsiders do nothing but try to say what a horrible wife I am. There is no winning with outsiders.
Both my mother/sister in-law are convinced that my husband is under my thumb. Oh my! If only they knew some of the stunts that he's pulled in over 42 years of marriage LOL! And yes, several times I've had to clean up the mess and put everything to rights. For the record the women in his family like their men folk to be biddable so neither of these women would tolerate a husband like their son/brother.
My father criticized me for having my voice slightly higher than usual at my husband. Told me my husband is deep down keeping things to himself to not get me upset.
I did every chore in the house. I kept out of trouble. I was determined to not be the stereotypical teenage girl. I got attacked anyway. I was forced into therapy for not being typical enough. Still seen as a bad daughter anyway.
Rabbi accused me of being controlling when I was upset the rabbi found out my child had special needs and the rabbi wanted to butt into our lives. I have a distrust of Jewish schools so I don't want others to make decisions for us. Says I get into my moods and controlling my husband. Same rabbi says my husband is the happiest in shul as other men are miserable by their wives. Go figure.
By me it was the other way around. My mother was very critical of me for as long as I could remember. I didn't know why--I was a good student, didn't get involved in drugs, sex, alcohol, running with a bad crowd, kept my room and stuff cleaned and in order, I even kept my orthodontist appointments all on my own. I don't know what she wanted from. I didn't go to her funeral and afterwards I heard that she was bad mouthing me to family and friends and claimed I'd had numerous abortions--I couldn't have children due to PCOS. Thank G-d my father spoke up for me and put all to right.
It is so sad when a parent [who is clearly mentally troubled] treats their child in such a horrendous way. It is even worse when you have had PCOS (a tough condition to deal with) and be met with so little understanding. It sounds great that your father stood up for you...
Sounds like you need to locate ANOTHER Rabbi. Not all are like the one you describe.
IF you have true Shalom Bayit, that is a Divine blessing and you should disregard what "others" say. Your husband is "happy" with you? You sound "happy" with him. What else is there?
The link to the author's website does not seem to be working.
I really strive to be a support to him. That is my sincere goal but it will require some retraining of my brain to do that consistently. It would be helpful if there was a course or series of lectures for women on this incrediblely challenging role we have. Can you suggest any resources?
Try The Empowered Wife, this book changed my life
Great book. Sara Rigler's course is based on this book
Hello Seattle Shadchan! Excellent article and I too value Sara Rigley’s books, especially Battle Plans.
The Kesher Wife Course by Sara Rigler promotes this thinking. See here: https://sararigler.com/workshops/the-kesher-wife-webinar/
Sara is also a prominent author on Aish!
I like RelationShift
Also, Rivka Malka Perlman is starting a course now
bsd
Hi There are a few I know of if you wish to call me