Aish.com Weekly Email - 260,000 subscribers


Aish.com delivered
  e-mail
  Aish Mobile

See More


Crash Course in Jewish History Part 33 - The Great Revolt
by Rabbi Ken Spiro
In a seemingly suicidal move, Jews decided to take on the might of Rome.

    Email this Print this

A rebellion against Rome in the 1st century CE would be the equivalent today of Israel declaring war on NATO. That's how mighty Rome was.

So how did the Jews decide to take on such a seemingly suicidal challenge? This question has a number of answers. Into the equation enter:

  • Ideological differences between the pagan Greco-Roman world and the monotheistic Jewish world
  • The Jewish response to the Roman domination which led to strife among the various Jewish factions: the Pharisees, the Sadducees, and the Zealots
  • Roman persecution of Jews which started with taxation and ended with outright slaughter

We will look at them one by one.

IDEOLOGICAL DIFFERENCES

Like the Greeks, the Romans worshipped many gods. Not only that, whenever they conquered a swath of land, they simply added the conquered peoples' gods to the Roman pantheon. The Roman historian Varro writes that by the 1st century BCE they had in excess of 30,000 gods. (1)

The Jewish idea of one invisible God, who demanded exclusive worship and could not be added to the big pot, was totally incomprehensible to the Romans.

But more importantly, along with Jewish beliefs went a lifestyle of obedience to a host of commandments that countered the Roman worldview. For example, the Jewish insistence on respect for life, was bound to irk a people who built amphitheaters just so the public could be amused by watching their fellow human beings be butchered, the more grotesquely the better.

The Talmud (in Megillah 6a) captures the difference in a very interesting statement:

Caesarea and Jerusalem: if someone will tell you, "both are destroyed," do not believe it; if someone will tell you, "both are standing," do not believe it. But if someone will tell you, "Caesarea is destroyed and Jerusalem is standing," or "Jerusalem is destroyed and Caesarea is standing" that you can believe.

Now we know for a historical fact that Caesarea and Jerusalem were standing at the same time. When Herod was alive, he built the city of Caesarea, and for sure he didn't destroy Jerusalem.

So what does this mean?

In making this statement the rabbis were making a theological, historical, and political point about the reality of the relationship between Israel and Rome, between the descendants of Jacob and the descendants of Esau.

What they meant is that in terms of the cosmic struggle one can't be on top without the other being down. When the Jews are up and Jewish values are strong, then Roman values are going to be down and so on. That's the cosmic struggle for the soul of humanity.

JEWISH STRIFE

The Jewish reaction to the presence of the Romans - who were dominating the Holy Land and worshipping idols - had many faces.

If you would like to receive "Jewish History" or other features via e-mail, please enter you email address here:




Our Privacy Guarantee: Your information is private. Your transactions are secure.
Aish.com, One Western Wall Plaza, POB 14149, Old City, Jerusalem 91141, ISRAEL
phone: (972-2) 628-5666 fax: (972-2) 627-3172 email: webmaster@aish.com

Judaism